EU Citizenship Needs a Stronger Social Dimension and Soft Duties
189
While it is true that all these facilitating initiatives provide tangible benefits only if there is a cross border element, their personal scope is potentially very wide: it goes well beyond the constituency of mobile workers,
affecting travellers and tourists, patients, students, consumers. Among ordinary people there is only a very limited awareness of these initiatives. The
first thing to do is thus to popularize these opportunities among the wider
public, disconnecting them from free movement in the thick sense (i.e. work
mobility).
A way of doing this would be to introduce an ‘EU social card’ (with a
number identifier) available to all European citizens to enhance the visibility
of (and also easing access to) the various privileges and services already
provided by the existing programs. In the US the social security number is
not only a pre-requisite for most contacts with the public administration, but
also a visible and tangible symbol of membership in the US legal space.
Italy has a similar code, which is called codice fiscale, requested for any
application to a public benefit, in addition to being used for tax purposes.
This number used to be shown on a dedicated plastic card, identifying each
citizen (and legal resident) primarily as a taxpayer. Smartly, the number is
now shown on a different card: the carta sanitaria – used to access the
National Health Service -– which evokes the idea of an entitlement associated to tax duties. A clever move in terms of integration and bonding.15
A more ambitious idea is to create a direct stake also for stay-at-homers
in the area of free movement. As has been aptly noted by various authors,
the freedom to move implies also the freedom to stay.16 Those who opt for
staying do not have access to the facilitating benefits and services that the
EU provides to the movers. Why not imagine a scheme offering, upon application, universal transferable vouchers (or drawing rights) that workers
could pass on to their kin – in particular sons and daughters wishing to
move? Such vouchers (each having a certain value) could be used to access
the existing benefits and services aimed for mobile workers or cashed in for
covering extra expenses linked to mobility. Every worker would be entitled
15
16
One should not underestimate the symbolic – in addition to the practical and
control-oriented – value of administrative papers in forging belongingness and
even bonding. See the interesting historical reconstruction by Torpey, J.
(2000), The Invention of Passports: Surveillance, Citizenship and the State.
New York: Cambridge University Press. On the importance of symbols and
everyday practices in EU building, see also the very interesting book by
McNamara, K. (2015), The Politics of Everyday Europe. Oxford: Oxford
University Press.
See the various responses to the kick-off essay by De Witte, supra, ft. 11.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents