130
Swider and den Heijer
an area without border controls, decisions on the residence of third-country
nationals, including stateless persons, taken by one Member State may have
effects on other Member States. As explained above, Member States’ practices
and legislation display considerable differences in the treatment of stateless
persons. This may have undesirable cross-border effects which can be countered by a common framework for the identification and protection of stateless persons.
Although one may argue that addressing protection gaps in the 1954
Convention falls primarily to the parties to the 1954 Convention rather than
the EU, it is to be observed that non-EU state parties do not necessarily have an
interest in harmonizing their implementation of the 1954 Convention to the
same extent as EU state parties—precisely because they do not partake in
the Union area of free movement.
6
Proposal for an EU Directive
The legislative act we propose should set out common goals in the field of
identifying stateless persons as well as their standard of treatment that all EU
countries must achieve. It would be up to the individual Member States to ensure that their national laws meet those goals. Although recent experiences with
secondary migration of asylum seekers prompted the European Commission
to issue proposals to transform the asylum directives into regulations,108 in respect of statelessness a directive would probably be a suitable legal act. Below,
we explain what the key legal elements of such a directive would be. It is neither useful nor necessary at this stage to go into each and every legislative detail. Yet we do outline the issues that need to be addressed at the very least and
how, in our view, the most critical issues should be resolved.
6.1
Statelessness Determination Procedure
An obligation on all Member States to have in place an accessible and fair procedure for the determination of statelessness would greatly improve the legal
position of stateless persons in many Member States. As noted above, a determination of statelessness is a logical prerequisite for invoking the rights set out
in the 1954 Convention.
Just as in the asylum context, a determination of the status of stateless
person is necessary for a person to be granted protection, including legal
108
C OM(2016) 466 final; COM(2016) 467 final.
European Journal of Migration and Law 19 (2017) 101–135