434
Melbourne University Law Review
[Vol 40:401
approach highlight the problems that occur when there is no clear legislative
basis for assessing statelessness.
B How is the ‘Country of Former Habitual Residence’ Determined?
Given that a stateless person is not a national of any country, the relevant
country of reference for assessing well-founded fear of being persecuted is the
‘country of his or her former habitual residence’. This is incorporated in the
definition of ‘receiving country’ in s 5 of the Migration Act.177
Hathaway and Foster suggest that a country of former habitual residence:
is an international legal term of art, assessed on the basis of a wide-ranging inquiry that would ordinarily include consideration of such factors as whether
the applicant was lawfully admitted to, and entitled to leave and return to, the
country; lived there for a significant period of time; and made it the center
of her interests.178
In the decisions examined for the purposes of the present analysis, some
decision-makers considered factors such as the applicant’s place of birth; the
time spent by the applicant in the ‘receiving country’; identity and travel
documentation held by the applicant; and the applicant’s links to the ‘receiving country’ with regard to education and employment in determining the
country of former habitual residence.179 In others, the decision-maker simply
accepted the applicant’s contention,180 or provided no reasoning at all or made
no finding about the applicant’s country of former habitual residence.181
The following Table summarises the places found to be ‘countries of former habitual residence’ in the decisions we considered.
177
The definition notes that for the purposes of the term ‘receiving country’ in the Act, ‘if the
non-citizen has no country of nationality — [it means] a country of his or her former habitual residence, regardless of whether it would be possible to return the non-citizen to the country’: Migration Act s 5 (definition of ‘receiving country’ para (b)).
178
Hathaway and Foster, above n 7, 75.
179
1106804 [2011] RRTA 1046 (21 December 2011); 1005911 [2010] RRTA 923 (20 October
2010); 1107430 [2011] RRTA 790 (8 September 2011); 1310456 [2014] RRTA 881 (17 December 2014); 1104223 [2011] RRTA 725 (25 August 2011); 1317610 [2014] RRTA 472
(28 May 2014); 1102027 [2011] RRTA 996 (17 November 2011); 0802865 [2008] RRTA 307
(20 August 2008).
180
1006929 [2010] RRTA 841 (27 September 2010); 1100132 [2011] RRTA 246 (29 March 2011).
181
N05/51687 [2005] RRTA 179 (31 August 2005); 1303526 [2013] RRTA 815 (19 November
2013).