Maskur Has/SOPA Images/LightRocket/Getty Images
World Report
Rohingya refugees off the coast of Indonesia
He says that the pandemic has put a
great deal of pressure on populations
that were already over-stretched. In
2019, 1·9 million residents of the
Indian state of Assam were left out of
the National Register of Citizens. “They
have been told they are not citizens,
because they cannot prove, through
a process that is both arbitrary and
discriminatory, that they have been
in Assam since before 1971”, explains
de Chickera. “They have expended all
their resources trying to appeal the
decision, getting more and more into
debt, and then COVID-19 arrives, and
they are not eligible for state relief
because they are now viewed as being
non-citizens.” By contrast, Sudan has
distributed food to vulnerable families
during the pandemic without requiring
identification.
The atmosphere in Malaysia
appears to have become more hostile
towards immigrants and refugees.
A photograph of a sign outside a
mosque in Johor state telling Rohingya
they were not welcome went viral.
At the end of February, 2021, more
than 1000 Rohingya were deported
from Malaysia to Myanmar. “There
is a real fear among refugees and
migrants in Malaysia that if they try
to access COVID-related care, they
will be detained”, said de Chickera.
Many countries shifted services online
during the pandemic, which has been
1530
problematic for stateless people
without stable internet connections.
25 of 45 European countries have
confirmed plans to vaccinate stateless
populations against COVID-19. They
will have to overcome vaccine hesitancy
in some communities, including
among Roma, who have good reason
to distrust the authorities. Countries
with small numbers of stateless
people might simply vaccinate them
along with the general population.
However, some nations are actively
discriminating against non-citizens. The
president of the Dominican Republic
has said that those without documents
will be excluded from the COVID-19
vaccination campaign, resulting in
concerns for the 210 000 residents of
Haitian origin who had their nationality
rescinded in 2013. An incomplete
campaign could be costly, particularly as
the Dominican Republic has reported by
far the most cases of COVID-19 of any
nation in the Caribbean.
Most countries with sizeable state
less populations are unlikely to be able
to start mass vaccination campaigns
this year. Furthermore, the number of
stateless people living in the country
might be unknown. Issuing information
on the vaccines in languages that
minority groups can understand might
not be a priority. “There is a very real risk
that a lot of stateless people will not get
the vaccine”, de Chickera told The Lancet.
UNHCR is working to ensure that this
does not happen. “There are two key
considerations”, explains Ann Burton,
Chief of the Public Health Section at
UNHCR. “The first is whether or not
stateless populations are mentioned in
national plans. The second is whether
they are able to get vaccinated, even
if they are mentioned.” Countries
that require a national identification
number for those who wish to obtain
a vaccination could issue temporary
numbers to irregular populations.
The COVAX Facility aims to ensure
that all participating nations have
enough vaccines to cover 20% of their
population. For cases in which supplies
are limited, many governments might
not prioritise non-citizens.
Gavi, the Vaccine Alliance, has
set up a humanitarian buffer, to be
deployed in places which have not
included populations of concern in
national vaccine plans. “The buffer
is designed as a last resort, to ensure
access to COVID-19 vaccines in settings
when there are unavoidable gaps; for
example, if the plans do not allocate
vaccines to displaced people, including
refugees, and asylum seekers”, explains
Burton. “It could potentially be used for
stateless populations as well.”
The diverse nature of statelessness
means interventions need to be
tailored. Ethnic Russians in Latvia are
deprived of political rights, but they
are well documented, with full access
to health care. They are unlikely to be
missed by public services. The same
cannot be said of uninsured Roma living
in ramshackle settlements, or stateless
people who are part of undocumented
migrant communities. Murray stresses
the importance of extending visas
and residency permits during periods
of emergency, such as pandemics. “If
you regularise stays as, for example,
Portugal has done, then you remove a
lot of the barriers for accessing health
care, state aid, and vaccination drives”,
she said. “It is a straightforward measure
and it would make a big difference.”
Talha Burki
www.thelancet.com Vol 397 April 24, 2021