the israeli incorporation regime49
plantationcolony’ fuelled mainly by a large low-paid and seasonal Arab
labour force and a smaller better-paid Jewish labour force. The contradiction between market-based colonialism and Jewish national aims resulting from the considerable use of Arab labour stimulated a change in the
colonial direction during the second major phase of immigration. The
arrival of Jewish immigrants during the Second Aliyah whose organized
workers formed the ranks of the Labour Movement generated a change in
the colonial struggle from the ‘conquest of land’ to the ‘conquest of labour’
as a central concern. However, despite this shift, Shafir contends that the
ultimate aim of furthering Jewish colonialism and establishing a pure settlement colony has remained unchanged.
This analysis is significant given the ripples it creates within some
of the most critical Israeli political circles. Any depiction of Zionism as
a colonial project is considered a provocation by the vast majority of
Israeli society, and translated to self-hatred and disloyalty to the state.
That said, as Israeli historian Ilan Pappé notes, the comparative colonial
discourse does appear among a few critical Israeli scholars who tend
to self-identify as the Zionist Left. But this too is a limited analysis. Pappé
explains:
Critical Israeli academicians … tend to see the year 1967 as a watershed
between a pre-1967 moral, contained and basically united Israel and a
post-1967 occupying, expansionist and divided Jewish state. Hence, they
are willing to point to colonialist features in the Israeli conduct in the occupied territories and trace all the present social and political predicaments
to the making of Greater Israel in 1967 (Pappé’s commentary in Shafir
1999, 81).
Shafir’s reformulation of Israeli history within the parameters of a
colonial-settler scheme, and one that simultaneously acknowledges the
“particular cast” of Zionist colonialism along with its “fundamental similarity with other pure settlement colonies,” refuses the above demarcation. The colonial logic of pre-1948 Zionism was amended in its post-1967
realization, yet remained central to the Zionist project of nation-building.
It is upon this understanding that this book seeks to examine the inclusive
and exclusive dynamics faced by Palestinian-Arab citizens in contemporary Israel. The colonial logic of pre-1948 Zionism will be shown to resurface in contemporary Israeli democracy, at the legislative, declarative,
structural, and operational levels. In other words, the historical matrix of
colonialism within which the Jewish national movement burgeoned is the
main source of the multifaceted racial discrimination faced by PalestinianArab citizens today.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents