6
introduction
expansion?These are the kinds of questions that notable scholars have
emphasized. By and large, the academic literature has tried to make analytical ‘sense’ of what it is that has led to a deepening internal and disparate disconnect between de jure and de facto citizenship for Arabs in
Israel. To this end, critical social scientists will often correctly point to an
absence of rights, identification and representation with formal Israeli
citizenship. In doing so, scholars have described the Israeli citizenship of
the Palestinians in a variety of ways, including: one-way citizenship, hegemonic citizenship, illusory citizenship, shrinking citizenship, ghettoized
citizenship, hollow citizenship, mere citizenship, something less than citizenship, and a citizenship emptied of real content.
But on the question of how the space for Palestinian citizenship has
(d)evolved, (de)generated, or been (re)drawn, the existing literature has
mainly focused on the structural, institutional, conceptual, sociological,
legal, racialized, historical, economic, and gendered tendencies within the
Israeli incorporation regime. Broadly speaking, the existing literature on
the exclusionary dynamics of Palestinian citizenship has mainly taken the
form of depicting it as missing something – as an incomplete or partial citizenship whose structure cannot be used to sustain a liberal democratic
society. Taken together, the question of how this deprived Arab citizenship
is formed and maintained, and the kinds of relations of exclusion that are
created, is often answered by describing the rights, freedoms, resources,
benefits, and discourses that are absent, exclusionary or made inaccessible.
This book does not contest these observations. On the contrary, it is
upon the impressive and rich critical scholarship on Palestinians in Israel
that this book is based. Working from this literature, the purpose here is
instead to conceptualize an analytical framework for understanding how
the dynamics of exclusion in Palestinian citizenship have developed. To
this end, it is argued that the means, the actual medium, through which, by
which, and from which marginalized Palestinian existence is maintained
in Israel is citizenship itself. As the chapters outline, it is the provision of
citizenship, the very inclusion within the Israeli citizenship regime that
creates the inherent contradictions and paradoxes of Arab citizenship in a
Jewish state. So, in contrast to other Western nation-states, the Israeli citizenship regime inverts the relation of exception embedded within the
classical model of liberal citizenship.9 It is Palestinian inclusion within the
9 Importantly, certain features of the relation of exclusive-inclusion (as explained in
Chapter Six) integral to Israeli citizenship may appear to readers as also being characteristic of the citizenship regimes to which indigenous populations are faced in the West,
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents