98
chapter two
Because the Israeli government prohibits any permanent physical or
structural development in unrecognized villages, residents are unable to
legally (re)build or repair existing homes, roads, educational and health
facilities, community centres, or sewage systems. Developing any of these
elements on one’s own property is accompanied by a constant threat of
eviction and demolition, which prevents many inhabitants of unrecognized villages from building new homes or developing existing ones. As a
result, unrecognized villages are usually very congested with high population densities as more than one family usually resides in a single house.
Israeli Apartheid: Beyond South Africa
Citizenship in Israel is funnelled through comprehensive policies of exclusion and their respective systems of control, paired with limited inclusion
in all socio-political spheres.116 This incorporation regime, maintained
through an uneven allocation of resources, rights and representation in
Israeli society, is legitimated through the way in which social membership
is conceived and granted within the state. As pointed to in this book, in the
case of Israel, the Jewish state is not only a source of identity but it is also
a particular guarantor of rights (Kimmerling 1999).117 This is because
Jewish identity in Israel provides an entirely new assemblage of rights irrespective of formal citizenship. Put differently, Jewish identity is automatically merged with Israeli citizenship.
Like other incorporation regimes, Israeli citizenship is composed of
“concentric circles” within which the boundaries of civic status for the
Palestinian community are distinctly rigid given their peripheral location
(Shafir and Peled 1998, 412). And so, this community is limited to a rigidly
defined citizenship located in the periphery, as any possibility for movement toward the centre requires a social mobility that is systematically
denied to it by virtue of the self-definition of the state as ‘Jewish’. In other
words, the fruition of social mobility requires more rights and greater
access to resources which, when denied, reduces Arab citizenship. An
examination of Israel’s formal and informal practices reveals that its incorporation regime is structured in the form of an apartheid state system:
legally enshrined systematic discrimination maintaining the dominance
116 A similar formulation is made by Ghanem (1998, 431).
117 For an in-depth account of how the Zionist incorporation regime fuses Jewish and
Israeli identity, see Chapter Five.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents