A/HRC/39/64
8.
To collect information, the members of the mission travelled to Bangladesh,
Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern
Ireland. The secretariat undertook numerous additional field missions between September
2017 and July 2018. The mission also held over 250 consultations with other stakeholders,
including intergovernmental and non-governmental organizations, researchers and
diplomats, either in person and remotely. It received written submissions, including some in
response to a public call.
9.
The mission strictly adhered to the principles of independence, impartiality and
objectivity. It sought consent from sources on the use of information, ensuring
confidentiality as appropriate. Specific attention was paid to the protection of victims and
witnesses, considering their well-founded fear of reprisals. The mission expresses its grave
concern at the intimidation and threats faced by persons cooperating with the mechanisms
of the Human Rights Council examining the situation in Myanmar. It urges Myanmar to
protect human rights defenders.
C.
Legal framework
10.
The mission assessed facts in the light of international human rights law,
international humanitarian law and international criminal law, as applicable in Myanmar. In
addition to non-international armed conflicts in Kachin and Shan States, the mission
considered that the violence in Rakhine State between the Arakan Rohingya Salvation
Army (ARSA) and the Myanmar security forces constituted a non-international armed
conflict, at least since 25 August 2017.2
III. Context
11.
A succession of military regimes have ruled Myanmar since 1962. In 2008, a new
Constitution was adopted, designed by the military to retain its dominant role in politics
and governance. It instituted a system of government with military and civilian components.
The Tatmadaw (armed forces) appoints 25 per cent of seats in both legislative bodies, and
selects candidates for three key ministerial posts (Defence, Border Affairs and Home
Affairs), and at least one of two Vice-Presidents. This is sufficient to control the National
Defence and Security Council and the entire security apparatus, and to block constitutional
amendments. The Tatmadaw has the right to administer and adjudicate its affairs
independently, without civilian oversight. Current or former military officers occupy
positions of authority across all branches of government, within the civil service and the
judiciary, and in many State-owned enterprises. In 2010, the Government led by Thein Sein
embarked on wide-ranging reforms towards political and economic liberalization, without
amending the Constitution. The National League for Democracy won the election held in
November 2015, and a Government led by that party took office on 31 March 2016.
Sanctions were lifted and foreign investment welcomed.
12.
In addition to the Bamar, Myanmar includes other ethnic groups that constitute 32
per cent of the estimated population.3 Since independence, the numerous ethnically-based
armed conflicts have been used by the Tatmadaw to justify its power, presenting itself as
the guarantor of national unity. Several groups hold deep-rooted grievances, struggling for
greater autonomy and an equitable sharing of natural resources. While Governments have
made overtures towards negotiated peace agreements, hostilities have continued. These
conflicts indicate that the nation-building efforts of the military have failed: there is no
unifying “Myanmar” national identity, and resentment against Bamar-Buddhist domination
has only grown. Notably, under military rule, the concept of “national races” has gradually
2
3
4
Assessment in line with that of the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC). See for
example, ICRC, “Rakhine: Returns must be safe, dignified and voluntary”, speech by the ICRC
President at the Shangri-La Dialogue, Singapore, 2 June 2018.
See 2014 Population and Housing Census of Myanmar (available from
http://myanmar.unfpa.org/en/publications/2014-population-and-housing-census-myanmar-data-sheet).