533US2
708
Unit: $U87
[10-21-02 18:35:10] PAGES PGT: OPIN
ZADVYDAS v. DAVIS
Kennedy, J., dissenting
Other provisions in § 1231 itself do link the requirement of
a reasonable time period to the removal process. See, e. g.,
§ 1231(c)(1)(A) (providing that an alien who arrives at a port
of entry “shall be removed immediately on a vessel or aircraft” unless “it is impracticable” to do so “within a reasonable time” (emphasis added)); § 1231(c)(3)(A)(ii)(II) (requiring
the “owner of a vessel or aircraft bringing an alien to the
United States [to] pay the costs of detaining and maintaining
the alien . . . for the period of time reasonably necessary
for the owner to arrange for repatriation” (emphasis added)).
That Congress chose to impose the limitation in these sections and not in § 1231(a)(6) is evidence of its intent to measure the detention period by other standards. When Congress has made express provisions for the contingency that
repatriation might be difficult or prolonged in other portions
of the statute, it should be presumed that its omission of the
same contingency in the detention section was purposeful.
Indeed, the reasonable time limits in the provisions just
mentioned simply excuse the duty of early removal. They
do not mandate release. An alien within one of these categories, say, a ship stowaway, would be subject as well to
detention beyond the removal period under § 1231(a)(6), if
the statute is read as written. Under the majority’s view,
however, it appears the alien must be released in six months
even if presenting a real danger to the community.
The 6-month period invented by the Court, even when
modified by its sliding standard of reasonableness for certain
repatriation negotiations, see ante, at 701, makes the statutory purpose to protect the community ineffective. The risk
to the community exists whether or not the repatriation negotiations have some end in sight; in fact, when the negotiations end, the risk may be greater. The authority to detain
beyond the removal period is to protect the community, not
to negotiate the aliens’ return. The risk to the community
survives repatriation negotiations. To a more limited, but
still significant, extent, so does the concern with flight. It