CITIZENSHIP AND STATELESSNESS
IN THE HORN OF AFRICA
\Y
who voluntarily acquire a foreign nationality after entry into force of the law may be deprived of nationality
by a ministerial committee.®
In Somalia,
the law and
citizenship
previous
constitution
is lost on acquiring
citizenship
residence
another
(Arts.2(b) and
conflict. The
(art.10(a)),
however,
and
Law
on Somali
that a person
4(c)); a former citizen may
in the territory and renouncing
Constitution of 2012,
1962
Citizenship
naturalising
provides that
must
renounce
recover citizenship by establishing
citizenship of any other country (art.12). The
states that “A person
who
a
is a Somali
Provisional
citizen cannot be deprived
of
Somali citizenship, even if they become a citizen of another country.”® In principle, the constitution has
superior authority; however, the lack of consistency creates uncertainty in application of the law.®6
The 2004 Transitional Federal Charter also permitted a person who acquired another nationality to retain
Somali citizenship. The status of those who lost citizenship on the grounds of acquiring another before
the 2004 Transitional Federal Charter entered into force is not clear (nor is the date the Charter entered
into force®’).
In practice,
a prohibition
on dual
indiscriminately to those who
were
nationality
creates
significant
born with entitlement to two
restricting the prohibition to those who
voluntarily acquire
risk of statelessness
(or more)
another
if it is applied
nationalities
nationality through
(rather than
naturalisation
based on residence in the other state, or marriage to a national of another state). A prohibition on dual
nationality creates particular risks of statelessness
if it applies to children as well as adults, meaning
that the person concerned has no opportunity to choose one nationality on reaching adulthood. Even if
this possibility is offered, many of those affected are likely to have no knowledge of the obligation to
make such a choice.
In the context of the Horn of Africa, it is very likely to be the case that a person with one or both parents
originating from another country has never taken any steps to acquire recognition of the other nationality,
for example by applying for a national identity card or passport. It is also very possible that even if the
person
did do so, they would
support.
be
refused
recognition
for lack of existing documentation
or witness
In practice, in the Horn of Africa as in other regions, those who are most at risk of statelessness
are those who are at the same time potentially nationals of more than one country — but who lack the
ability to prove a connection to either state.
84 Eritrean Nationality Proclamation (No. 21/1992, section 2(5), 4(2)(e), and 8(1)(a).
85 Provisional Constitution of Somalia 2012, art.8(3).
86 The Somaliland Citizenship Law adopted in 2002 provides that a Somaliland citizen by birth may acquire the citizenship of another country without losing
citizenship; however, renunciation is required for those acquiring citizenship by naturalisation. Dual citizenship is, moreover, not permitted for women who
marry a foreign husband and acquire his nationality. Somaliland Citizenship Law, 2002, arts. 4 & 9.
87 Delegates to the Somalia National Reconciliation Conference held in Kenya adopted a draft of the Transitional Federal Charter at a plenary meeting of the
Conference on 15 September 2003.
The draft outlined a five-year mandate leading to the establishment of a new Somali constitution and national elections.
On 29 January 2004, some Somali leaders involved in the negotiations signed a document which proposed amendments to the September 2003 version of the
Charter.
However, not all faction leaders signed. The Somali National Reconciliation Conference formally concluded on 14 October 2004 with the swearing-in
of Colonel Abdullahi Yusuf Ahmed as President of Somalia. See UN Secretary General reports to the Security Council on Somalia, 2004 — 2008, collated at
https://www.ohchr.org/EN/Countries/Pages/SecretaryGeneralReportsSO. aspx.
26
UNHCR
— December 2021