In other cases, stateless individuals may be
detained for much longer periods of time.
U.S. law provides that all non-citizens detained following a final order of removal have
the right to release after six months if they
can demonstrate that there is “no significant
likelihood of removal in the reasonably foreseeable future”.93 Nonetheless, some stateless persons have been detained beyond the
six-month period, due in part to difficulties
establishing a lack of nationality and the inability to obtain travel documents. There
are currently no mechanisms to ensure that
statelessness is consistently identified and
taken into account when making custody determinations in the post-final order context.
Enhancing immigration officials’ understanding of statelessness and providing the appropriate staff with training and tools to enable
them to identify statelessness would greatly
facilitate their ability to recognize when a detained individual is or may be stateless. Such
efforts, combined with clear procedures and
policies for follow-up once an assessment
is made that an individual may be stateless
would in turn better ensure that lack of nationality does not result in indefinite detention in the context of post-final order custody
determinations.
A related concern is what happens to stateless individuals with a final order of removal
but for whom removal is not reasonably foreseeable after they have been released from
detention. The regulations provide for release
under an order of supervision requiring the individual to: (1) appear before an immigration
officer periodically for identification; (2) submit, if necessary, to a medical and psychiatric
examination; (3) give information under oath
about his or her nationality, circumstances,
habits, associations, and activities, and any
other information requested by the authorities; (4) obey all applicable laws and other
reasonable written restrictions on conduct or
activities; (5) continue to seek travel documents, assist authorities in obtaining such
documents, and provide the authorities with
all correspondence with relevant embassies
Solutions for the Stateless in the U.S.
requesting the issuance of travel documents;
(6) obtain advance approval of travel beyond
previously specified times and distances; and
(7) provide notice of change of address.94
Stateless individuals faced with this regime of
supervised release with no foreseeable end
date have unsuccessfully challenged such
conditions under a variety of constitutional
theories.95
Most stateless persons in the United States
who are subject to orders of supervision remain in this condition of perpetual legal limbo with at times serious restrictions on all aspects of their life in the United States, unable
to leave the country and unable to fully participate in society. The United States recently
revised its policy guidance on the use of discretionary agency authority to set reporting
requirements for individuals with final orders
of removal who are being released from detention.
In an August 2012 policy memorandum, the
Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS)
Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)
explains to its officers that reporting requirements “may be reassessed and modified
based on the alien’s level of compliance, ICE’s
detention and enforcement priorities, changes to the circumstances of the individual case,
and as a matter of discretion”.96 Applied with
appropriate consideration of the particular
intractability of statelessness, this new guidance should increase the likelihood that the
reporting requirements for stateless individuals will be reasonable and not onerous. This
new policy is an example of positive agency
action that, if applied appropriately and consistently, will alleviate one of the burdensome
restrictions often imposed on stateless individuals in the United States. An important
next step, however, will be to issue specific
guidance and develop training to ensure the
memo is effectively implemented.
21