and the Palestinian Authority can’t easily arrange for an ambulance to cross
the [Israeli] checkpoint to enter the town. In the case of the man who was run
over by the tractor, by the time the ambulance arrived, people had managed to
lift the man from underneath the tractor, but his condition was really bad. The
other case was my own uncle. When the ambulance arrived, my uncle was
already dead and there was no more need for it but to carry out his body.”
A. Abeid, Nabi Samuel.
Interview: 6 February 2017
Old City of Hebron
Hebron is a large commercial city in the south of the West Bank, known for
being both an important religious site and the only Palestinian city besides
Jerusalem to contain Israeli colonies within its urban area. The case of
Hebron also provides a unique example of how service provision policies
can be engineered to create two diametric environments for two peoples
within a single area. This difference within service provision is enabled by
the geopolitical division of Hebron into two parts. Hebron 1 (H1) consists
of 80 percent of the city and is under the administration of the PA. Hebron
2 (H2) consists of the remaining 20 percent, encompassing the Old City
as well as the Israeli colonies established in the city, and is under full
Israeli control.252 Service provision for the 6,000 Palestinians living in H2 is
delegated to the PA,253 despite the fact that Israel as an occupying power is
ultimately responsible for this task. In addition to shirking its duties, Israel
also obstructs the PA’s efforts in H2, leading to a de facto denial of services
for Palestinians living in the area.254
Services routinely denied to Palestinian neighborhoods within H2 include
water, electricity, sanitation, transportation, basic maintenance, and
emergency medical and fire services.255 Palestinians in H2 suffer from the
same water restrictions and rationing experienced by other Palestinians in
the West Bank, while the colonies are connected to a constant supply of water
252 Protocol Concerning the Redeployment in Hebron, PLO-Isr., 17 January 1997, Article 2/a/1,
available
at:
http://www.mfa.gov.il/mfa/foreignpolicy/peace/guide/pages/protocol%20
concerning%20the%20redeployment%20in%20hebron.aspx [accessed 22 August 2017].
253 OCHA oPt, Fragmented Lives: Humanitarian Overview 2015, June 2016, 21, available at: https://www.
ochaopt.org/sites/default/files/annual-humanitarian-overview_10_06_2016_english.pdf
254 BADIL, Forced Population Transfer: The Case of the Old City of Hebron, Bethlehem: August 2016, 44,
available at: http://badil.org/phocadownloadpap/badil-new/publications/research/working-papers/
CaseStudyFPT-Hebron(August2016).pdf [hereinafter, BADIL, Old City of Hebron].
255 Id., 41.
71
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents