the term national but it has not treated
nationals as its citizens. The US Constitution
also has only referred the citizens. The United
States Immigration and Naturalization Act,
1952 has regarded the residents of places like
Samoa which are not included in the union as
the American nationals but does not regard
them as its citizens. Even in Nepal, there
may be persons who might have stayed for a
long period in Nepal and may have attained
a certificate that would identify him as a
Nepali citizen being issued by government
offices, local bodies, government owned
corporations and educational institutions, and
recommendations of the Village Development
Committees and Municipalities that someone
is a Nepali citizen. Such person may be the
national of Nepal but not its bona fide citizens
as per Chapter 2 of the Interim Constitution of
Nepal, 2007 and Nepal Citizenship Act, 2006.
Court may strike down such law to the extent
of such inconsistency. To look in this premise,
there is an evident provision in Article 65(a)
of the Interim Constitution that a person
has to be a Nepali citizen first to become a
member of Constituent Assembly. Therefore,
the provisions enshrined in Section 11(1) and
(2) of the Electoral Rolls Act, 2006 that ‘land
ownership certificate, identity cards issued by
government offices, local bodies, government
owned corporations and educational
institutions, and recommendations of the
Village Development Committees and
Municipalities may be acceptable ‘used
after the ‘citizenship certificate’ has to be
maintained that the legislature has framed
law by exceeding its jurisdiction. The other
documentary evidence cannot substitute the
citizenship certificates. Hence, that provision
does not seem to be consistent with the
provisions of Article 65(a) and Section 5(1) (A)
of the Electoral Rolls Act, 2006. It is also found
to be inconsistent with the provisions of Article
25 of the ICCPR.
12. The Constitution is the fundamental law of
the land. Nepal has a written Constitution
and Article 1 of the Constitution proclaims
that the Constitution is the fundamental law
of the land and the law inconsistent with it
shall be void to the extent of its inconsistency
and therefore, Nepal is a country that has
Constitutional supremacy. Pursuant to Article
1, the Constitution is the fundamental law of
the land and the law inconsistent with it shall
be void to the extent of its inconsistency and
Article 107(1) has entrusted this Court with the
extraordinary jurisdiction to declare any law
void that is inconsistent with the Constitution.
This implies that though the legislature is
sovereign to legislate any laws, it has to make
law without violating constitution or same
without contravening with the Constitution.
In case any law is inconsistent with the
Constitution, this Court reserves the power
pursuant to the Article 107(1) of the Interim
Constitution to declare such law null and void
by exercising its extraordinary jurisdiction.
14. In Article 63 of the Interim Constitution
of Nepal, 2007 it is provided a Constituent
Assembly shall be constituted for the making of
a new constitution. After the commencement
of the Interim Constitution, a Constituent
Assembly has been constituted and the process
of Constitution drafting has already begun.
Pursuant to the provisions of Article 63(7),
the members to the CA have been elected by
the Nepali citizens, who have completed 18
years of age by the 15th December, 2006. The
duration of CA constituted pursuant to Article
63(1) is specified in Article 64. Article 82 holds
that the function of CA shall terminate from the
day the Constitution approved by it is brought
into commencement.
15. The CA constituted pursuant to Article 63 is
not a legislature that would be constituted
in every 4 or 5 years that gets continuity.
The Constituent Assembly is constituted
only for drafting a republican Constitution
of a democratic federal structure so as to
translate the popular movement of 2006
into reality. The Constitution shall be written
within the duration stipulated in Article
64 and the function of CA shall terminate
from the day the Constitution approved by
it comes commencement, as laid down by
Article 82. Moreover, the Interim Constitution
lacks a provision for another election for
the Constituent Assembly and the election
of Constituent Assembly has already been
conducted. Therefore, the provisions of
Electoral Rolls Act, 2006 may be incongruent
13. The legislature parliament of Nepal is
sovereign. However, since it is a creature
of Interim Constitution of Nepal, 2007, it
cannot formulate laws against its creator, or
contradicting with the Constitution itself.
Stating in Constitutional terms, the legislatureparliament is sovereign and supreme in framing
laws. However, due to the provision of Article 1
of the Constitution, Nepal has Constitutional
supremacy rather than parliamentar y
supremacy. Therefore, legislature parliament
may formulate legislation subject to the
limitations of Constitution. In case any
law framed by the legislature parliament is
inconsistent with the Constitution, then this
38
Compilation of Selected Decisions of Supreme Court on
CITIZENSHIP and BIRTH REGISTRATION
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents