Statelessness in the European Union
‘stateless’, in line with a common statelessness determination procedure set up by
the EU, to two years of habitual residence. 64
With the institution of EU citizenship no longer tied to Member State
nationality, stateless persons would hypothetically be able to benefit from the
rights attached to citizenship of the EU in several respects. First and foremost,
stateless persons would be able to legally reside in a Member State having been
granted the status of ‘EU citizen’, which is both directly and indirectly beneficial.
Residency rights are unconditionally available to nationals of a state, leaving
stateless persons with the requirement of obtaining a residence permit. For a
variety of reasons, among which are difficulties in producing identification
documents, it may be difficult for stateless persons to obtain a residence permit
and achieve legal residence. 65 The lack of such legal residence and the irregular
presence on the state’s territory make insecurity and fear an everyday reality for
stateless individuals. 66 Fear of arrest, detention or even expulsion when state
authorities discover their irregular presence or lack of identification documents
leave stateless persons hesitant to engage in activities that require them to get
involved with such authorities. As a corollary to the lack of legal residency,
stateless persons furthermore find themselves unable to exercise their right to free
movement, both domestically and internationally. 67 It goes without saying that EU
citizenship, especially with its accompaniment of freedom of cross-border
movement and residence, has the potential of directly resolving the issue of legal
residence. This would provide stateless individuals with increased security
regarding their residency, as well as increased confidence in their presence on the
territory. It furthermore has the potential to prevent them from being detained or
expelled on grounds of illegal residence.
Access to government and public services, such as health care and quality
education, may also be facilitated through the grant of legal residence. In the
absence of a nationality, legal residence commonly constitutes a prerequisite for
admission to educational and healthcare facilities, and prevents individuals from
64
65
66
67
This is in line with international law. See, eg, Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness,
opened for signature 30 August 1961, 989 UNTS 185 (entered into force 13 December 1975)
art 1(2)(b). The easing of this legal residency requirement also serves to prevent the
emergence of the following paradox: EU citizenship is expected to be beneficial because it
could provide stateless individuals with legal residence (see below), but proof of legal
residence constitutes a requirement for eligibility for EU citizenship.
No Country of One’s Own: An Advisory Report on Treaty Protection for Stateless Persons in
the Netherlands (Report, Advisory Committee on Migration Affairs 2014)
<https://www.adviescommissievoorvreemdelingenzaken.nl/binaries/adviescommissievoorvr
eemdelingenzaken/documenten/publicaties/2014/09/11/no-country-of-one%E2%80%99sown/No_country_of_ones_own_ACVZ_report_20140911.pdf>. See also Caroline Sawyer
and Brad Blitz, Statelessness in the European Union: Displaced Undocumented, Unwanted
(Cambridge University Press 2011).
‘This Is Our Home’: Stateless Minorities and Their Search for Citizenship (Report, UNHCR
2017)
<https://www.unhcr.org/ibelong/wpcontent/uploads/UNHCR_EN2_2017IBELONG_Report_ePub.pdf>. In an interview
conducted with a stateless person living in the Netherlands, it was noted that this could even
mean that stateless persons ‘…do not make an attempt to have themselves registered as
“stateless” because they are afraid of expulsion or imprisonment’, even though they could be
granted additional rights on the basis of this status. Interview with Lena, a stateless person
living in the Netherlands (Anne Brekoo, Tilburg, 27 February 2019)). The author has obtained
permission to include excerpts of the interview in this article.
van Waas (n 34) ch 10.
35