Implementing judgments in the field of asylum and migration on odd days
3
Table of contents
Executive summary
4
I. Introduction
5
II. Legal framework for the execution of judgments
II.1. CJEU rulings execution mechanism
II.2. ECtHR judgment execution mechanism
6
6
7
III. Methods of non-implementation of judgments
9
IV. Examples of (non)implemented judgments:
common themes among the studied countries
IV.1. Immigration detention
IV.2. Non implementation of relocation decisions, European Commission
v. Czech Republic Hungary, Poland, joined cases C 715/17, C 718/17
and C 719/17
IV.3. Collective expulsion and access to asylum
IV.4. Access to classified data in national security cases
IV.5. Statelessness
IV.6. Effective remedies against expulsion
IV.7. Not following the court’s instructions in repeated asylum procedures
on the merits
12
12
19
20
27
29
32
35
V. Conclusions
38
Annex I: List of CJEU rulings in the field of asylum and migration
Annex II: List of ECtHR judgments in the field of asylum and migration
42
44