By April 3, 2009, notification of nationality acquisition was filed by 252 persons under
the amended Nationality Act and the certificate of nationality acquisition was issued to
116 persons96.
Children Whose Parents are Unknown
Article 2(3) serves as an important means to prevent statelessness. “A child shall ... be a
Japanese national when both parents are unknown ... in a case where the child is born in
Japan.”97 The interpretation of this provision received attention in the “Baby Andrew”
case. Andrew was born in 1991 at a hospital in Komoro City, Nagano Prefecture. The
mother disappeared five days after his birth. He was initially issued an alien registration
card as a Philippine national, but the Philippine Embassy rejected this nationality, and
he therefore was re-registered as stateless. From the fact that he was born in Japan to
unknown parents, the case was taken to court to confirm his Japanese nationality under
Article 2 (3) of the Nationality Act.
The main issue at trial was whether the “parents are unknown” provision applied to his
case, and the burden of proof. The District Court and the High Court produced
contradicting conclusions, but the Supreme Court recognized Andrew’s Japanese
nationality in 1995:98
The Act … provides that a child who was born in Japan shall be a Japanese
national when both father and mother are unknown or have no nationality
(Article 2(iii)). If the principle that the nationality of a child shall depend on
the parents’ nationality is to be maintained, a child whose father and mother
are unknown will be stateless. Therefore, in order to prevent the occurrence
of stateless persons, the … Act recognizes the acquisition of Japanese
nationality by a child in such a situation. Therefore, “when both father and
mother are unknown” in Article 2(iii) means when both father and mother
96
www.moj.go.jp/MINJI/minji174.html.
The dominant view in Japan is that in the application of the Nationality Act, being on Japanese
territory includes onboard a Japanese ship sailing the high seas and aboard a Japanese airline flying over
international waters. The United Nations Convention on the Reduction of Statelessness (Article 3) does
not limit the place of birth to the high seas or open skies. However, if the child is born when flying over a
territory or sailing in territorial waters of a certain state, s/he will have two countries of birth. “As a
non-signatory of this convention, we cannot adopt this interpretation for the Japanese Nationality Act”.
Kidana supra note 3, pp.201.
98
Judgment of the Supreme Court (Second Petty Bench January 27, 1995).
97
39