PRACTICAL GUIDE ON NATIONALITY
•
Where applicants submit relevant documents proving or indicating their nationality or
statelessness, these should always be assessed against the background of their
asylum claim. There may be cases where the document submitted may establish
nationality but is in direct contradiction with the statements of the applicants
concerning other material facts (e.g. passport received in person in the country of
origin after the applicant’s alleged date of departure).
Keep in mind that one piece of evidence alone may be sufficiently probative to support the
credibility of the material fact as well as to confirm it (e.g. presenting an authentic national
passport). On the other hand, a piece of evidence that is not probative of the material fact on
its own (e.g. birth certificate) may support, in combination with other evidence and the
statements of the applicant, the credibility of the material fact.
Point to remember
The credibility assessment combines the assessment of documentary and other evidence,
the assessment of the applicant’s statements and the consideration of factors that may lead
to distortions.
This section will present different types of evidence which can help substantiate an applicant’s
nationality (or lack thereof) and highlight certain specificities in this regard:
•
Statements by the applicant;
•
Documentary evidence;
•
Country of origin information;
•
Other evidence.
5.1.
Statements by the applicant
Statements may be the only evidence that an applicant can provide to assert their country of
origin. Additionally, and in particular for the applicant who states that they (exclusively) hold
one nationality, statements may indicate that they may actually hold another (additional)
nationality. This may be evident through the information they provide, such as their place of
birth, nationality of family members and past residency.
Statements can be oral or written, collected during the personal interview or at previous
stages of the procedure. When no other, or only limited, documentary evidence is available, it
can be especially useful during the personal interview to explore certain topics to help
establish the credibility of the person’s alleged nationality or statelessness.
43