Category F [Failure of naturalization and restoration of previous nationality] Persons who
renounced their previous nationality in the naturalization or nationality restoration process
who nevertheless failed to acquire another nationality (Sample cases from Pakistan,
China/Bolivia)
Category F is statelessness that arises from situations where persons apply for
naturalization or nationality restoration and in the process renounce their previous
nationality with the expectation that their application would be accepted, but nevertheless
they fail to acquire another nationality.
In < Case 11 >, a couple and their child with Pakistani nationality applied for naturalization
in Japan and renounced their Pakistani nationality based on an instruction by a legal affairs
bureau at the time when their grant of naturalization had been informally decided.
However, immediately thereafter, it became apparent that the husband had a history of
having been deported from Japan and that his (re-)entry to Japan and naturalization
application were made under a false name; consequently, the entire family had their
naturalization application denied and became stateless.
In < Case 12 >, an individual who had Chinese nationality acquired Bolivian nationality
through naturalization and renounced his Chinese nationality in his 40s, but later he had a
change of mind and wished to restore his Chinese nationality. He renounced his Bolivian
nationality during a short-term stay in Japan according to an instruction by the Consular
Section of the Chinese Embassy in Japan; however, his application for restoration of
Chinese nationality was not granted later, and he became stateless.
1. < Case 11 > A person who, after renouncing the original nationality, was not granted
the expected Japanese nationality by naturalization
A, who has Pakistani nationality, came to Japan in the late 1990s as a student. However,
A quit school and continued to stay in Japan despite the fact that his residence permit as
a student had expired; he was deported to Pakistan.
In the 2000s, A re-entered Japan with a false passport under a false name and was
staying in Japan with the status of a long-term resident. Later, his wife also came to Japan,
and they had a child in Japan. In 2001, in the process of applying for naturalization, A and
his family renounced their Pakistani nationality and became stateless, as they were
instructed to submit a certificate of renunciation of Pakistani nationality.
Subsequently, A’s period of stay in Japan expired, but he thought it was unnecessary
to extend his period of stay because his naturalization procedure was underway. Without
the extension of the period of stay, he became a so-called over stayer. When this fact
was pointed out by the legal affairs bureau, A appeared at an immigration bureau. When
90
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents