338
THE GEORGETOWN ENVTL. LAW REVIEW
[Vol. 35:331
TABLE A:
CLIMATE CHANGE AND STATELESSNESS
Requirement
Climate Threat
Possible Remedy
Permanent
Population
Environmental displacement
caused by wave-driven flooding
or loss of freshwater.
Permanent relocation funded by
loss & damage mechanism.
Defined
Territory
Sea level rise causing territorial
loss and uninhabitability.
Set-aside of physical territory in
neighboring nation funded by loss
& damage.
Functioning
Government
En masse displacement following extreme weather event.
Consent of host nation to function
as government in exile.
Capacity for
Diplomacy
Climate diaspora, loss of a functioning government.
Consent of host nation to conduct
foreign relations & exercise sovereign powers within host nation’s
borders.
Of the four indicia of statehood, climate impacts as applied to island nations
will likely first cause the loss of a permanent population on a nation’s homeland.
Though international law contemplates the loss of statehood due to absorption,
merger, or dissolution of physical territory, climate change poses a novel threat to
this statelessness calculus.42 A nation’s physical territory will be lost to environmental impacts, never to be assumed, merged, or dissolved into another nation.
International law must take steps to accommodate this problem, balancing traditional notions of statehood with climate realities.43 For example, the U.N.
Convention of the Law of the Sea and customary international law governing territorial sea and maritime baselines does not take into account habitable lands lost
to the ocean.44 Would these nations lose their territorial sea or be classified as a
rock or low-tide elevation?45
42. Matthew C.R. Craven, The Problem of State Succession and the Identity of States under
International Law, 9 EUR. J. INT’L L. 142, 145 (1998); Jeffrey L. Blackman, State Succession and
Statelessness: The Emerging Rights to an Effective Nationality Under International Law, 19 MICH. J.
INT’L L. 1441, 1444–1445, 1180–1181 (1998) (discussing state succession issues arising out of the
dissolution of the former Soviet Union and Yugoslavia).
43. Professor McAdam has examined new legal models such as a government in exile, which allows
a State to continue even when the territory is no longer habitable. Professor McAdam has examined new
legal models such as a government in exile, which allows a State to continue even when the territory is
no longer habitable. McAdam, supra note 6, at 106. See also Maxine Burkett, The Nation Ex-Situ: On
Climate Change, De-territorialized Nationhood and the Post-Climate Era, 2 CLIMATE LAW 345, 359
(2011).
44. See Alan Boyle, Law of the Sea Perspectives on Climate Change, 27 THE INT’L J. OF MARINE &
COASTAL L. 831, 831–838 (2012).
45. Id.
Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=4223806