Another interesting statistical categorization in the information provided by the Border Guard
service is the group of persons “whose nationality is unknown”. It is not clear why this category
is separate from the categories of “stateless” and “persons not claiming any nationality”.95 The
interpretation applied by Eurostat may be instructive in this regard as it considers that the category
“unknown” shall include persons for which no information on individual citizenship is available. This
understanding is, thus, based on a technical inability to make a determination of citizenship which
may reflect a temporary or a permanent situation. When interviewed, the Border Guard service
highlighted that sometimes the inability to make a conclusive determination of nationality may be
attributed to the non-cooperation of the foreigner in the process, driven by the fear of removal and
the aim to prevent possible deportation. On the other hand, there may be cases where although the
foreigner is not at fault, the determination cannot take place due to a disability, the person’s age or
other special circumstances influencing the person’s status. Such circumstances should be taken
into account during the determination of citizenship process.
3.4.2 Other rights of applicants and recognized stateless persons
3.4.2.1 THE RIGHT OF RESIDENCE
The current Polish legal framework severely limits possibilities for the regularization of stay for
which stateless persons would be eligible. Due to the link between statelessness and irregular
status in Poland, often the only procedure for regularization that could be applicable in such cases is
initiating return proceedings with a view to receiving tolerated stay based on the unenforceability
of the return order or permit for humanitarian stay where applicable.96 It should be underlined,
however, that return proceedings are not adapted to carrying out a proper statelessness
determination as this process is driven by different objectives and primarily aims to enable removal
to a given country. In most, if not all, cases, there is no country to remove stateless persons to.
The main obstacle to obtaining a residence permit is not only the obligation to submit a valid travel
document – obtaining an exemption from this condition in practice, although permitted by law, is
extremely difficult — but also the requirement of continuous legal stay in Poland until the day of
filing the application.97 In the overwhelming majority of cases, these conditions cannot be met by
stateless persons in Poland.
3.4.2.2 PERMANENT RESIDENCE AND NATURALIZATION
Pursuant to Article 195(1)(6) of the Act on Foreigners, permission to settle is afforded inter alia
to a foreigner who has been living in Poland based on the tolerated stay permit continuously for
a minimum of 10 years. However, the wording of this provision explicitly excludes foreigners who
received tolerated stay due to the unenforceability of the removal order. As a result, such stateless
persons who received a permit for tolerated stay according to the above circumstances would not
95
Analysis of the context and available case law leads to a conclusion that most of these categorizations focus on different
stages of the process of identification. Thus, a person who is under a “stateless” category is a person in relation to
whom statelessness has been established. “Person not claiming any nationality” is a person in relation to whom such a
conclusive determination has not been made, but the procedure is not completed, so the person in question could be, at
a later stage, considered as stateless.
96
Article 351(9) of the Act on Foreigners.
97
This requirement stems from the wording of Article 100(1)(9) of the Act on Foreigners.
UNHCR POLAND, SEPTEMBER 2019
35