Can’t Stay. Can’t Go. Refused asylum seekers who cannot be returned
9
and Carter 2016: 15), “A State’s refusal to
recognise a person, its continued silence, or its
demands for ever more evidence may eventually
constitute a failure to consider the person as a
national under the operation of its law.” Section
4.6.1 of the Home Office (2016h: 16) instruction
on statelessness recognises that “where an
individual has provided evidence that they have
made an application to the national authority only
to find more and more evidence requested by the
State in question, combined with long delays”, this
“in practice amounts to a denial of recognition”.
The majority of those who make a Stateless
application are refused asylum seekers. However,
some applicants have never made an asylum
claim and there is no requirement to do so. There
is no fee to pay to submit a Stateless application,
but the form is currently available only in English.
With the exception of Scotland, legal aid is
generally not available in the UK for advising,
representing or assisting someone who wishes
to make an application for leave to remain as a
stateless person, despite such applications often
being factually and legally complex. Legal advisors
can apply for exceptional case funding, but this
involves a significant amount of work for the legal
advisor and they will receive limited remuneration
only when exceptional case funding is granted
(Woodhouse and Carter 2016).
The burden of proof rests with the applicant in
the statelessness procedure and they must prove
a negative: that he or she is not considered a
national of any State. The standard of proof is
also higher than the reasonable degree standard
applied in refugee status determination. While
an application is pending, the individual has no
right to work and, currently, access to only basic
support may be available under Section 4.
If the application is successful, the person can be
granted leave to remain for 30 months, after which
they can apply for a further 30 months’ leave.
After five years, a stateless person can make an
application for indefinite leave to remain.
If the application is unsuccessful, there is no freestanding right of appeal to the independent Firsttier Tribunal. Rejected applicants can only apply for
administrative review or judicial review, or make a
new application.
The Red Cross submitted a freedom of information
request to the Home Office related to Stateless
applications. According to the reply received,
between 1 April 2013 and 30 June 2016, a total
of 1,662 people lodged a Stateless application
(Draper 2016). Of these, 1,096 had previously
applied for asylum. As of 30 June 2016, the total
number of people who had a decision on their
Stateless application was 854 and 41 people have
been granted leave to remain on their Stateless
application (Draper 2016).
1.4 The suffering and limbo
facing those who cannot be
returned
Refused asylum seekers who, through no fault of
their own, cannot be returned to their country of
origin risk falling into crisis. Without the right to
work and with limited or no statutory support, the
Red Cross sees people every week who are in
desperate situations stemming from their position
in society and the world as a person without
immigration status. Yet the option of returning to
their country of origin is not open to them.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents