2022
Statelessness & Citizenship Review
4(1)
during childhood, along with physical and mental disorders, negatively affects
educational outcomes and future employment and income, which in turn affects
the health of adults and their children, thus producing a vicious cycle.23 The built
environment of homes, streets, parks and safe spaces influences the pattern of
injuries, car accidents and obesity, and the general wellbeing of children. 24 Here,
it is worth emphasising that the World Health Organization (‘WHO’) defines
health as not simply the absence of disease, but as a state of complete physical,
mental and social wellbeing, which is in line with many Indigenous
conceptualisations.25 Similarly, international human rights law considers the right
to health to encompass ‘a wide range of socio-economic factors that promote
conditions in which people can lead a healthy life’.26 State policies that shape the
accessibility of early education, urban planning, affordable housing, citizenship
and welfare influence to a large extent the built and social environments in which
a child develops and achieves — or does not achieve — the full definition of
health.27 Naturally, the social determinants of health, including impoverishment,
diminished educational opportunities, racial discrimination and dispossession, are
largely a function of state institutions, non-state actors and their associated
structures and systems.
A structurally competent approach to understanding and analysing health
requires an interpretation of individual symptoms, attitudes or diseases as
stemming from upstream decisions, actions and designations. 28 Deploying such
an approach in grappling with the reality of Jerusalem points inevitably to a
necropolitical economy of life and death that renders some lives more valuable (or
more disposable) than others. Necropolitics is a concept, like genocide, that ‘is
never far from discussions of settler colonialism’.29 To appropriately situate
Palestinian child health determinants, we must combine insights from the settler
colonialism and public health literatures, organising them within ShalhoubKevorkian’s framework of unchilding.
THE POLITICAL AND RACIAL CONTOURS OF PALESTINIAN STATELESSNESS IN
JERUSALEM
Understanding statelessness in Jerusalem and its effects on child health requires a
critical examination of the settler colonial and racially exclusivist nature of
Zionism, which constitutes the Israeli state’s raison d’état of displacing,
dispossessing and dominating the Indigenous Palestinian people across historic
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
Diane D Allensworth, ‘Addressing the Social Determinants of Health of Children and Youth:
A Role for SOPHE Members’ (2011) 38(4) Health Education & Behavior 331, 331.
Susan Kay Cummins and Richard Joseph Jackson, ‘The Built Environment and Children's
Health’ (2001) 48(5) Pediatric Clinics of North America 1241.
‘Constitution of the World Health Organization’, World Health Organization (Web Page)
<https://www.who.int/about/governance/constitution>.
United Nations Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, General Comment No
14: The Right to the Highest Attainable Standard of Health (Article 12), UN Doc
E/C.12/2000/4, 2 [4] (‘Highest Attainable Standard of Health’).
Karen Villanueva et al, ‘Can the Neighbourhood Built Environment Make a Difference in
Children’s Development? Building the Research Agenda to Create Evidence for Place-Based
Children’s Policy’ (2016) 16(1) Academic Pediatrics 10.
Jonathan Metzl and Helena Hansen, ‘Structural Competency: Theorizing a New Medical
Engagement with Stigma and Inequality’ (2014) 103 Social Science & Medicine 126.
Wolfe (n 5) 387; Achille Mbembe, ‘Necropolitics’ in Stephen Morton and Stephen Bygrave
(eds), Foucault in an Age of Terror (Palgrave Macmillan 2008) 152.
92