The Need for Principles
on Citizenship Stripping
Following two years of research and consultations,
ISI, Open Society Justice Initiative, the Asser
Institute and the Ashurst Law Firm are in the
final stages of developing a set of Principles on
Deprivation of Nationality as a National Security
Measure and an accompanying Commentary to the
Principles. The Principles restate international law,
reflect existing standards and draw on practices that
guide and limit State power to deprive persons of
their nationality as a national security measure. The
Commentary provides further background analysis
and discussion of the international law standards
and norms upon which the principles are grounded.
The Principles have been developed through
extensive consultation with global experts in the
fields of human rights, statelessness, national
security and counterterrorism, and related fields of
migration, refugee rights, child rights, discrimination
and international law. On the margins of ISI’s
World Conference, an expert meeting was held to
discuss the progress made with this project and
hear thoughts and feedback from experts around
the world on a draft text of the Principles. Those
consulted include leading academics, UN Special
Rapporteurs, UN experts, senior diplomats and
litigators.
The ISI team is now finalising the Principles and
Commentary, which will be launched in the Spring
of 2020, marking the start of a “year of action”
against citizenship stripping as a political weapon.
Over the course of the year, we will engage in
concerted efforts to draw attention to this issue and
develop and share resources to raise awareness
and bring to the fore, the international standards
that states are obligated to uphold. A series of
launch events, academic seminars and debates
and UN side-events will be complemented by the
implementation of a media and outreach strategy
as well as the development and dissemination of
further resources. The Principles and Commentary,
as well as ISI’s World’s Stateless Report (see box to
the right), will be at the heart of this year of action, as
we step up efforts to draw attention to, and combat
practices of arbitrary deprivation of nationality.
World’s Stateless Report:
Arbitrary Deprivation of
Nationality
In 2020, ISI will publish the third edition of its flagship
World’s Stateless Report, this year, focusing on
the theme of Arbitrary Deprivation of Nationality.
The report, which will complement the publication
of the Principles on Deprivation of Nationality as a
National Security Measure and Commentary, will
bring together research and analysis on historical
and contemporary practices of deprivation of
nationality, which has impacted both individuals
and entire communities. The report will feature
chapters on relevant international standards,
comparative research on deprivation of nationality
as a national security measure and a discussion of
cases of mass deprivation of nationality as a result
of race discrimination and situations of precarious
citizenship. The latter will include a focus on mass
deprivations against the Rohingya, Dominicans of
Haitian origin and Assamese of Bengali origin in
India. A further chapter will provide the perspectives
of leading experts from different fields, including
political science, security and philosophy on the
phenomenon of denationalisation. The report will
also include an exclusive interview with UN Special
Rapporteur on contemporary forms of racism and
xenophobia and ISI Advisory Council Member,
Tendayi Achiume.
As with previous World’s Stateless Reports, this
third edition will also feature an overview and
reflection on the state of statelessness in the world
today, with a number of country analyses as well
as a special feature to mark the halfway point of
UNHCR’s #IBelong campaign to end statelessness
by 2024.
30