e-flux Architecture
Positions
03/22
Photograph of a convoy of people, including communities of Sikh farmers, migrating to East Punjab with belongings and livestock, naturalized within the
landscape as part of the “Great Migration” series. Margaret Bourke-White, Migration in India (1947).
It took over not only the homes and lands of “evacuees,”
those who had fled, but also those imagined as leaving:
creating the ambiguous category of “intending evacuees,”
it dispossessed one religious community to give
occupations to refugees of another.6 As religious
minorities were forced out of dense, multi-religious
neighborhoods that had been forged over generations,
these evacuations and occupations haunt these cities to
this day. Names left on buildings, abandoned temples,
perfumeries, bakeries, and other small businesses
continue to signpost roots and uprooting. Partitions
violently created the territorial contours of new nations,
and are inscribed everywhere into built forms.
Muslims became citizens of the newly carved Pakistan,
equally large numbers became Indians, trailed by the
specter of political and spatial incommensurability. In
cities like Delhi, the new Nehruvian state planned “Muslim
zones” as part of its commitment to inclusion under
secularism, to provide enclaves for the safety of those who
stayed on.8 Muslim ghettos have ever since been
stigmatized as “mini-Pakistans,” and anti-Muslim violence
has often included the taunt of “go to Pakistan.” The
spatial logics of omnipresent partitions organize how we
live with difference now.
The Partition of 1947 was driven by the Muslim question in
India, about where Muslims as a political community
belonged in the new age of nationalism.7 This idea, of
partition, thrust all religious minorities, but especially
those who remained where they had always lived, into new
liminalities within and between nation-states. While some
Planning the Nation
Where refugees could not be accommodated in the
homes and lands of those “evacuated,” densely inhabited
camps, unplanned but not without design, offered a highly
regulated yet perennially temporary spatial arrangement.
03