Jirair,
19, Georgia.
© U N H C R / K . S H A R TAVA
Stateless children recounted situations where their
families had incurred serious debts after borrowing
from friends and neighbours to pay medical bills.
King (19), from the Akha hill-tribe community in
Thailand, remembers when his brother, also stateless,
had a serious car accident: “For him to be treated, we
had to pay the foreigners’ price. My mum borrowed
a lot of money from a neighbour. She is still paying
it back.”
Pratap (15) from Malaysia recalls how, after severely
injuring his leg playing football, his lack of nationality
was still the first consideration for the hospital: “I
felt angry because no one wanted to help me, even
when I was clearly in pain. They scrutinized my status
even though it was an emergency. Is it my fault that
I don’t have a nationality? I was born in this country
like any other Malaysian. Why do I have to suffer this
way?”
14
Risk-taking,
humiliation and psychological scars
For some, seeking assistance or loans to access health
care was not even an option. Unable to provide
the necessary documentation to obtain treatment
and unable to afford the high costs, the family of
Jirair (19) in Georgia took the risk of treating him at
home despite the seriousness of his injuries. “When
I was younger,” says Jirair, “I broke my leg. Even
though I needed to, we didn’t go to the emergency
department of the hospital because we knew that
without [nationality] documentation we would not
be admitted. I was treated at home. I took a long time
to heal – it was really hard”.
The constant humiliation of not being able to
prove one’s eligibility for treatment was raised as a
significant impediment by a number of participants.
Elena, a stateless mother in the Dominican Republic,
S TAT E L E S S N E S S R E P O R T
remembers the battle she waged to convince the
medical staff at the hospital to help her child: “It is
humiliating not being able to present documents. Even
at the hospital I was told that I couldn’t get treatment
for my baby because we didn’t have documents. They
only helped us after long persuasion.”
Kavita (22) in Malaysia explains how being stateless
made her hesitant to get medical attention, even
when it was clear that she needed it: “Lately I have
been coughing a lot. And there has been blood. I
visited a clinic and took medication but it didn’t
work. The clinic told me to go to the hospital, but
to go there is very embarrassing. They ask a million
questions about where I am from because I don’t have
proof of nationality. They are suspicious and it makes
me feel like I am stealing something. So I can’t go.”
Tragically, a childhood of living with statelessness
appeared to have extracted a serious psychological
toll on a significant number of the participants.
Individuals frequently described themselves as
“invisible”, “alien”, “living in a shadow”, “like a street
dog” and “worthless”. Others, like Paloma (16) in
the Dominican Republic described the paradoxical
sentiments of belonging yet being excluded. Says
she: “I feel Dominican, regardless of documents, but
people see me as less Dominican because of my lack
of documents.” In Malaysia, a dejected Kavita has
thought of drastic actions. “Sometimes I feel that I
should attempt suicide,” she says. Only thinking of her
family has prevented her from taking that route.
Leli (19), who had been stateless since birth but
recently acquired Italian citizenship, spoke of her
difficulties in coming to terms with her new identity
as a national: “Even though I now have Italian
nationality,” she says, “being stateless stays inside you
– like a permanent mark.”
S TAT E L E S S N E S S R E P O R T
15