THE ARRIVAL OF ‘STATELESSNESS STUDIES’?
DAVID BALUARTE *
In my symposium contribution, I provide my view that the study of statelessness
has emerged as a multi-disciplinary field and urge that we institutionalise it as
such. Statelessness is fundamentally a legal concept. The definition of ‘stateless
person’ specifically refers to the operation of law, and the protections envisioned
by both the 1954 and 1961 Conventions afforded to stateless persons are legal in
nature. 1 At the same time, formal legal reasoning has proven inadequate to fully
understand statelessness and protect stateless persons. Moreover, factual
statelessness enjoys few legal protections, but is essential to a more robust
understanding of nationality and what its absence really means. Accordingly, the
study of this legal concept should happen across disciplines to ensure that we take
appropriate steps to integrate effectively stateless persons legally, politically, and
socially, in the communities where they live.
The most important indicator that the field of statelessness studies has emerged
is the abundance of scholarly work on this topic that both fascinates and vexes the
global community. Once conceived as a technical problem of harmonising state
nationality laws, 2 statelessness gained a humanitarian dimension after World War
II. 3 Large-scale statelessness, which occurred after the fall of the Soviet Union and
the Former Yugoslavia, brought its relationship to geo-politics into focus. Due to
the hardening of both national borders and rhetoric about national identity in
response to a recent increase in global forced migration, people who fall outside
of the world order of nation states face risks as pressing as they have at any point
in contemporary history. In 2014, Mark Manly and Laura Van Waas observed that
‘there is enough [scholarly] activity to conclude that statelessness has “arrived” as
a recognized focus of both academic and policy-oriented study’. 4 The precipitous
rise in scholarly work with practical and theoretical applications even since that
2014 declaration clearly marks the emergence of statelessness studies as a field.
*
1
2
3
4
David Baluarte is an Associate Clinical Professor of Law at the Washington and Lee
University School of Law, where he directs the Immigrant Rights Clinic.
Convention Relating to the Status of Stateless Persons, opened for signature 28 September
1954, 360 UNTS 117 (entered into force 6 June 1960); Convention on the Reduction of
Statelessness, opened for signature 30 August 1961, 989 UNTS 175 (entered into force 13
December 1975).
Peter J Spiro, ‘Citizenship, Nationality, and Statelessness’ in Vincent Chetail and Celine
Bauloz (eds), Research Handbook on International Law and Migration (Edward Elgar 2014)
283.
Guy S Goodwin-Gill, ‘Introductory Note to the Convention Relating to the Status of Stateless
Persons’ (2010) United Nations Audiovisual Library 1.
Mark Manly and Laura Van Waas, ‘The State of Statelessness Research: A Human Rights
Imperative’ (2014) 19(1–2) Tilburg Law Review 3, 4.