Book Review: Citizenship
In the 1920s, the League of Nations issued documentation to hundreds of
thousands of refugees and stateless persons dispersed throughout Europe in the
wake of the Bolshevik Revolution and Armenian genocide. 42 While these ‘Nansen
passports’ (named for the Norwegian diplomat appointed to handle refugee
affairs) did not confer citizenship rights, they ‘protected individuals from
deportation and extended re-entry rights’. 43 In the US, no citizen can lose
citizenship against their will, adopting a default position in which persons retain
US citizenship when naturalising in another country. 44 Some countries — such as
the United Kingdom, Australia, Denmark and Canada — have adopted measures
to expatriate persons (usually dual nationals so as to avoid statelessness)
implicated in terrorist activities. 45 This practice harkens back to the earliest
principles allowing for expatriation on the basis of serving in hostile foreign
forces, but risks of abuse and discrimination arguably outweigh the actual utility
of preventing terrorism. 46 In recent years, Bahrain has terminated citizenship of
hundreds of political dissidents for terrorism-related offenses. 47 According to
Spiro, ‘[n]o country appears to expatriate individuals for common criminal
activity’. 48 With respect to gender equality, the 1979 Convention on the
Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women affirms
nondiscrimination in the application of nationality laws, in contrast to the ‘nearuniversal practice’ prevailing in the nineteenth century of terminating the
nationality of women who married foreign men. 49 In some cases, however, women
can still lose their original citizenship if they naturalise in another state through
marriage. 50
Spiro also provides in Chapter Five a concise and comprehensive overview of
statelessness, ‘the condition in which an individual lacks formal citizenship in any
country’. 51 He describes and provides examples of causes, such as conflict of
nationality laws; state dissolution and state succession; and discrimination on the
basis of religion, ethnicity or gender. He notes positive steps to combat
statelessness, such as increased ratifications of statelessness treaties and stronger
initiatives undertaken by the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in
the last two decades. 52 Arguably missing is a rough sense of the extent of the
problem of statelessness — the Institute of Statelessness and Inclusion estimates
the number to be at least 15 million — and why states and international bodies
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
ibid 117.
ibid 117–18.
ibid 121.
ibid.
ibid 122–23.
ibid 119. See also Fatiha Belfakir, ‘Activists: Bahrain Continues to Revoke Citizenship of
Dissidents’, VOA News (6 November 2018) <https://www.voanews.com/extremismwatch/activists-bahrain-continues-revoke-citizenship-dissidents>.
ibid 119.
ibid 115; Convention on the Elimination of All Forms of Discrimination against Women,
opened for signature 18 December 1979, 1249 UNTS 13 (entered into force 3 September
1981).
ibid 117.
ibid 129.
ibid 133.
365