Statelessness Working Paper Series No. 2017/08
to the bottom’ phenomenon.68 The recurring failure of the Common European Asylum System is a good
example: Member States deliberately lower their standards of protection to decrease relative
attractiveness in comparison to other Member States to avoid having to handle asylum-seekers. The
same thing could happen in the case of stateless persons.69 This is pointed out by Swider and den Heijer
as well, who are nevertheless in favour of an EU directive on statelessness.70 The author notes that the
fear of the pull-effect should not hinder Member States to comply with their obligations, but a
transparent and effective implementation of such directive, if adopted, should be a priority.
Whether including statelessness as a separate ground for EU-harmonised protection is going to happen
or not, the EU should keep advocating for the rights of stateless persons both within and outside its
borders. As long as a statelessness-specific EU directive is not considered a political possibility, the EU
should promote the idea of creating national statelessness-specific mechanisms in the Member States.71
To this end, the EU should further encourage the remaining Member States—Cyprus, Estonia, Malta,
and Poland—to accede to the 1954 Convention. Statelessness should also continue to be on the agenda
of the EU’s foreign policy: raising awareness of situations of statelessness and discriminatory nationality
laws, and promoting solutions in other parts of the world could possibly decrease the number of
stateless migrants arriving in the EU.72 The external promotion of addressing statelessness, at the same
time, encourages the EU to adhere to the ‘practice what you preach’ principle.73
3.3. The Council of Europe: routes to the codification of implicit obligations for statelessness
determination
Notably, the Parliamentary Assembly and the Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe have
adopted several soft law tools on the prevention and reduction of statelessness. However, the
identification and protection of stateless persons seem to have been of secondary importance on their
agendas. In CoE soft law, only sporadic mentions are found on the need to establish statelessness
determination procedures. In 1955, Parliamentary Assembly Recommendation 87 (1955) was issued,
calling for member States to sign and ratify the 1954 Convention without delay.74 In 1983, Committee
of Ministers Recommendation No. R (83) 1 on stateless nomads and nomads of undetermined
nationality called for States to accede to the 1954 Convention, and to apply it. Expressly asking for its
application signals that the Committee of Ministers acknowledges that the 1954 Convention is not
working properly without a statelessness determination procedure.
In April 2014, the Parliamentary Assembly released Resolution 1989 (2014) on the access to nationality
and the effective implementation of the ECN.75 The Resolution begins by recalling that the ECN
68
Gábor Gyulai, ‘Statelessness in the EU Framework for International Protection’, European Journal of Migration
and Law 14 (2012), p. 294.
69
Maarten den Heijer and Katja Swider, ‘Why Union Law Can and Should Protect Stateless Persons’, Amsterdam
Centre for European Law and Governance Research Paper No. 2016-03, p. 16. Available at:
http://ssrn.com/abstract=2823627 [accessed 18 April 2017]
70
Ibid.
71
Ibid.
72
Inge Sturkenboom and Laura van Waas, ‘How real is the risk of a “stateless generation” in Europe? Reflections
on how to fulfil the right to a nationality for children born to refugee and migrant parents in the European Union’
(2016), available at: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=2877368 [accessed 12 September
2017]
73
European Network on Statelessness, ‘Submission to the European Commission Consultation on the future of
Home Affairs policies: An open and safe Europe – what next?’ (January 2014), available at:
https://ec.europa.eu/home-affairs/sites/homeaffairs/files/what-is-new/publicconsultation/2013/pdf/0027/organisations/ens-european-network-on-statelessness_en.pdf [accessed 4 April
2017]
74
Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly Recommendation 87 (1955) on statelessness (25 October 1955)
75
Council of Europe Parliamentary Assembly Recommendation 1989 (2014) on access to nationality and the
effective implementation of the European Convention on Nationality (9 April 2014)
13