Sadiq 2008). The term “effective statelessness” aptly describes the political, social, and
even geographic exclusions experienced by those whose own country fails to recognize
them as such. My hope for the following discussion is that careful use of concepts specific to
the operations of citizenship in question and statelessness in question may better inform
ongoing debates about statelessness and the politics of ineffective citizenship.
Effective Statelessness: Examples in Latin
America
Academic inquiry with respect to citizenship in Latin America has tended to focus on
equality, participatory democracy, and access to government services rather than
acquisition of citizenship status or proof thereof. As a result, statelessness in the Western
Hemisphere has drawn little attention, necessitating reliance on reports by government
and human rights groups.
As a general rule, de jure statelessness in the Western Hemisphere is thought to be
uncommon, in large part because predominant migration patterns are into jus soli regimes
from countries that also recognize citizenship status for most births occurring outside the
nation. In theory, at least, a claim of citizenship as a matter of law would normally exist for
the vast majority of the population.
The notable exception is the Dominican Republic, which recently changed from a jus
soli regime to jus sanguinis, creating an estimated 200,000 stateless persons of Haitian
descent (Fullerton 2014, 148). From 1929 until 2010, the Dominican Republic awarded
6
Electronic copy available at: https://ssrn.com/abstract=3150558