IDLO AND UNHCR
Inclusive and participatory
system of governance
It is rare for stateless people to be
given a seat at the decision-making
table when it comes to crafting laws
and policies that determine their
legal status and the conditions in
which they must live. As a result,
even well-meaning initiatives to, for
example, grant stateless persons
in a migratory context a pathway to
regularise their legal status and to
facilitate their naturalisation can be
beset with problems. This can be
because such processes have failed
to account for the lived reality of being
stateless which can include a lifetime
of illiteracy, making it impossible to
understand information provided,
fear of authorities which can hamper
uptake, and poverty, which can render
even the most minimal application fees
prohibitive.
In order to embody key principles
of the rule of law, laws and policies
must be shaped with the meaningful
participation of those affected by such
laws and policies. For this reason, the
rule of law is predicated on governance
systems that are accessible,
responsive, and accountable to
everyone in a given society. The
Secretary-General’s report Our
Common Agenda acknowledges that
“a vibrant social contract guarantees
the conditions for people to live a
decent life, leaving no one behind and
enabling all to participate in society,
as promised in the 2030 Agenda”.32
Participation is a fundamental
requirement of public decisionmaking that ultimately guarantees
that laws represent the collective will
of all people and underpins the social
contract between the State and the
governed; it is also a substantive right
on its own, enshrined in international
human rights law.33 An inclusive and
participatory system of governance
places people at the centre of justice as
the key to ensuring that the rule of law
extends human rights and fundamental
freedoms to “all persons,” not merely
its citizens.
Box 6: Resolving Makonde statelessness in Kenya
In Kenya, the stateless Makonde people were able to resolve their plight in close cooperation with civil society
organisations, the Catholic Church and UNHCR. In July 2016, the Makonde community, supported by the Kenyan Human
Rights Commission (KHRC), petitioned the President to be registered as Kenyan citizens. In October 2016, around 300
members of the Makonde community embarked on a four-day trek from Kwale to Nairobi to seek an audience before
the President to present a new petition calling on the President’s office to ensure that the Makonde and other stateless
persons would be recognised as Kenyan citizens. The march gave significant visibility to the plight of the Makonde and
had a galvanising effect. As a result, the President issued a directive that all eligible stateless Makonde be registered
as Kenyan nationals and issued with Kenyan identity cards by December 2016, which eventually led to the resolution of
their statelessness at the end of 2019.
Box 7: Addressing stateless children in the Brazilian diaspora
In Brazil, strong and effective lobbying by civil society led to the resolution of the situation of stateless children in
the Brazilian diaspora. In response to a 1994 Constitutional Amendment that rendered children of Brazilians abroad
stateless, members of the Brazilian diaspora joined together to form a civil society movement called Brasileirinhos
Apatridas to push for legal reform. Due to active engagement with the media, both in countries of the diaspora and in
Brazil, and strong lobbying by Congress, Brasileirinhos Apatridas was able to effect legal reform that resolved the
statelessness problems that were created by the 1994 Constitutional Amendment.34
11