BOOK REVIEW
STATELESSNESS AND CONTEMPORARY ENSLAVEMENT
BY JANE ANNA GORDON (ROUTLEDGE 2019). 164
PAGES. PRICE USD $34.36. ISBN 9780367358549
YURIKO COWPER-SMITH *
Although having gained a footing in international law, statelessness research is
slowly developing into a cross-disciplinary area of scholarship and connections to
other legal and human rights issues are becoming more and more apparent. 1 As
one such overlapping topic, Jane Anna Gordon’s new book Statelessness and
Contemporary Enslavement looks at how statelessness and enslavement are
related. 2 On the surface, they may seem like discrete and disparate phenomena,
unfortunate anomalies in a world that is moving towards progress and modernity.
However, as we will learn, they are much more closely associated than one may
initially think. Gordon’s aim is to delve directly into this thorny intersection. Her
ambitious book explains how these two forms of extreme vulnerability and
exclusion — statelessness and enslavement — are neither anomalies nor
exceptions. They are deliberate processes and outcomes that were (and still are)
embedded in the ways in which the international state system and global economic
model of capitalism were developed and are maintained today. Rather than
viewing statelessness as an isolated legal issue or enslavement solely as a human
rights issue, Gordon studies statelessness and enslavement together because they
tell us about the political processes that lead to both conditions. To Gordon, the
forces that generate statelessness are the ones that also cause people to be at risk
of slavery.
So, what exactly are these political processes? Towards the end of the book,
Gordon asks how the ‘vulnerability generated by contemporary political economic
conditions [became] opportunities for highly lucrative profit-making’? 3 For her,
the extraction of labour from vulnerable others, whose exploitation is normalised
and made invisible, is reflective of our deeply unequal and precarity-generating
systems of economic and political governance. In her view, these forces, which
cause the dilution or the degradation of citizenship — that is evidently taking place
— is key to understanding how we end up with statelessness and enslavement in
the present.
Gordon does not exclusively study statelessness and enslavement to understand
how we got to where we are today. She also argues that there is value in
understanding the production of statelessness and enslavement because, through
their understanding, we can begin to discuss how to make our political institutions
more sustainable and equitable. She astutely asks:
*
1
2
3
Dr Yuriko Cowper-Smith holds a PhD in Political Science from the University of Guelph.
She researches diaspora-led social movements, forced migration, statelessness and genocide.
Maria Recalde-Vela, Sangita Jaghai and Caia Vlieks, ‘The State of Statelessness Research: 5
Years Later’ (2019) 24(2) Tilburg Law Review: Journal on International and Comparative
Law, 139–41.
Jane Anna Gordon, Statelessness and Contemporary Enslavement (Routledge 2019).
ibid 103.