This provision provides permanent residence – and even
naturalisation, should permanence residence be granted and
ordinary residence attained for a period of five years or more49 – for
persons who do not satisfy any of the ordinary provisions applicable
to immigrants wishing to remain on the territory.
One of the main barriers that stateless persons face in accessing
the most common immigration permits is the requirement of a
passport and police clearance from their country of origin.
Typically, stateless persons do not have passports and given that no
country recognises them as a national, no country will assist in
providing a police report. Where an immigrant cannot be removed
from the territory due to statelessness, but has no means to legalise
his or her stay on the territory under any of the ordinary provisions
of the Act, no other mechanism exists to protect his or her right to
acquire nationality other than the exemption process. The above
provision thus presents the only means by which most stateless
persons may access legal status and a path to naturalisation in this
country.50
The Immigration Act also regulates the detention and
deportation of illegal foreigners on the territory. Please refer to
section 8 below for in depth analysis of how to assist detained
stateless persons.
At present, the immigration laws, policies and practices of most
states do not sufficiently take into account the unique
characteristics that set stateless persons apart from other migrants.
All non-stateless migrants have an effective nationality, benefit from
the protection of their state and have a country to be returned to.
Stateless persons however, are not considered nationals under the
operation of the law of any state, and the de facto stateless do not
have an effective nationality. Both groups lack the protection of a
nation state, and are unlikely to have consular or diplomatic
protection and/or documentation. The failure to recognise the
particular circumstances of statelessness has created a protection
gap; this is most evident in the context of immigration detention
for the purpose of removal.
There are Guidelines to Protect Stateless Persons from Arbitrary
Detention51 which provide detailed guidance on how states should
treat stateless persons in the context of immigration detention in
order to comply with their obligations under international human
49
50
51
30
As per section 5 of the Citizenship Act.
Stateless persons who have travel documents or passports are able to apply for
other regular immigration permits. Alternatively, a stateless applicant must
request administrative discretion in waiving requirements for common
immigration permits.
The Equal Rights Trust, Draft Guidelines on the Detention of Stateless Persons,
2011 available at: http://www.equalrightstrust.org/view-subdocument/in
dex.htm?id=830.
Promoting citizenship and preventing statelessness in South Africa: A practitioner’s guide