22. In order to determine statelessness in full accordance with the 1954 Convention, a
statelessness determination procedure should be accessible to everyone within the
Swiss territory, and it should be fair and efficient.56 The procedure should be formalised
in law and observe due process guarantees.57 The procedure under the APA is mainly
written. Oral hearings or court proceedings are only approved in exceptional
circumstances. People who submit an application for recognition of statelessness in
Switzerland often have a migration background, face language barriers, difficulties
evidencing their statelessness, and are unfamiliar with the country’s legal system, so a
written procedure puts them at a disadvantage. Switzerland should follow good practice
and UNHCR guidance and ensure that the procedure can be initiated either orally or in
writing, that provisions for ex officio initiation of the procedure are applied in practice,
and that the individual circumstances of all applicants are carefully considered in line
with UNHCR guidance.58
23. Currently, the statelessness determination procedure does not include access to
adequate legal aid and provision of interpreting and translation services. Legal aid is
rarely granted during the application process, even though applicants have a right to
legal aid at all stages of the procedure if they meet certain requirements.59 Translation
and interpreting services are not provided, despite being difficult to arrange and costly
for the applicant. In the absence of procedural guarantees and safeguards set out in law,
this lack of support for applicants is particularly problematic in what is a very complex
procedure.
24. Information and counselling about the procedure should be widely disseminated in
order to facilitate access to the procedure. 60 Additional procedural and evidentiary
safeguards for child applicants should be put in place, including ‘priority processing of
their claims, provision of appropriately trained legal representatives, interviewers and
interpreters as well as the assumption of a greater share of the burden of proof by the
State.’61 Government officials who may come in contact with stateless persons through
their regular work (for example, social services or immigration control) should be trained
to identify potential applicants and should refer them to the determination procedure.62
Finally, authorities involved in the identification of stateless persons should be provided
with training on statelessness and the rights of stateless persons.
25. According to Article 31(1) of the Federal Act on Foreign Nationals (FNA) persons
recognised as stateless in Switzerland have the right to be granted a residence permit in
the canton in which they are legally residing. So far, courts have not decided whether
this requirement to reside legally in a canton entails a ´lawful stay´ requirement based
on which persons recognised as stateless could be refused residence status if they had
no prior right to stay. However, legal doctrine and practice have interpreted Article 31(1)
56
UNHCR, ‘Handbook on protection of stateless persons', (2014), note 12, para. 63, para. 68 and para. 69, available at:
https://www.refworld.org/docid/53b676aa4.html.
57 Ibid. note 12, para. 71.
58 Ibid. note 12, para. 71, para. 87, para. 94 and para. 101.
59 Federal Administrative Court in case E-5581/2013 of 28 November 2013.
60 UNHCR, ‘Handbook on protection of stateless persons', (2014), note 12, para. 68, available at:
https://www.refworld.org/docid/53b676aa4.html; UNHCR, ‘Global Action Plan to End Statelessness’, (November 2014),
available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/545b47d64.html; UNHCR, ‘Good Practices Paper – Action 6: Establishing
Statelessness Determination Procedures to Protect stateless Persons’, (July 2016), p. 5, available at:
http://www.refworld.org/docid/57836cff4.html.
61 UNHCR, ‘Handbook on protection of stateless persons', (2014), note 12, para. 119, available at:
https://www.refworld.org/docid/53b676aa4.html.
62 UNHCR, ‘Good Practices Paper – Action 6: Establishing Statelessness Determination Procedures to Protect stateless Persons’,
(July 2016), p. 4, available at: http://www.refworld.org/docid/57836cff4.html.
8