Introducing ‘unwanted’ noncitizens 59
Figure 4.1 Elena and Ramadan outside their caravan (Denis Bosnic, 2015).
upon liberal democratic principles.70 This further demonstrates the interrelationship of citizenship and noncitizenship and the need to recognise the reality
of noncitizenship.
In Denis Bosnic’s photograph, taken near Rome, Elena and Ramadan embrace
outside the caravan where they live with their sons. They are some of a number
of individuals who have worked with Bosnic in order to raise awareness in Italy
about the situation for stateless persons. Elena has Romanian citizenship, but
because Ramadan is stateless, they have not been able to register their marriage.
Their children are not registered as Ramadan’s, but instead as fatherless. In this
way, they have been able to claim the citizenship of their mother. The entire
family is affected by a noncitizen, indeed a stateless vulnerability to the State
and the State system. That is, statelessness not only affects Ramadan’s ability to
act in the world, but also makes those close to him vulnerable to the State system
70 A discussion of the impact of Swedish border checks of travellers from Denmark and how it fits
within wider developments is found, for example, in Tim Marshall (2016) Prisoners of Geography: Ten Maps that Tell You Everything You Need to Know About Global Politics, Elliott &
Thompson Ltd, p. 107. For more on the involvement of non-State actors in border management,
see for example Gallya Lahav (2003) ‘The Rise of Non State Actors in Migration Regulation in
the United States and Europe: Changing the Gatekeepers or Bringing Back the State?’,
pp. 215–241 in Nancy Foner, Rubén Rumbaut and Steven Gold (eds) (2003) Immigration
Research for a New Century, Russell Sage Foundation.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents