Page 28
PERSONAL STATUS
WHAT’S THE ISSUE?
Sex discrimination in personal status laws negatively
impacts the ability of women to conduct various aspects
of their daily lives. For the purposes of this report, we are
categorizing personal status laws to include, beyond family
law and marital relations (see marital status section),
particularly laws that govern rights to confer citizenship, as
well as travel, participation in public life, etc.
The sexism and stereotypes inherent in many laws - laws
permitting “marriage” of girls to adult men, the impunity
for rapists who marry their victims, the requirement of “wife
obedience” - are obvious. In other laws, the stereotypes upon
which they are based may be less obvious but are nevertheless
ingrained. For instance, in the very recent past in Europe and
the U.S., the message around nationality law has been subtle.
Married women and men can pass their nationality to their
spouse or children equally, but there is inequality in the law if
they are unmarried; then a father must actively claim paternity
and alone guarantee financial support. This is sexist towards
both women and men.
Beijing Platform for Action recommendations
Strategic Objective 1.2. Ensure equality and nondiscrimination under the law and in practice
Actions to be taken by Governments:
•• 232(d) - Review national laws, including customary laws and
legal practices in the areas of family, civil, penal, labour and
commercial law in order to ensure the implementation of the
principles and procedures of all relevant international human
rights instruments by means of national legislation, revoke
any remaining laws that discriminate on the basis of sex and
remove gender bias in the administration of justice;
•• 232(b) - provide constitutional guarantees and/or enact
appropriate legislation to prohibit discrimination on the basis of
sex for all women and girls of all ages and assure women of all
ages equal rights and their full enjoyment
What’s the impact?
Sex discriminatory personal status laws violate women’s civil
and political rights. In almost 25% of countries around the
world, women, and some men, are excluded from giving their
nationality or citizenship to their children and/or spouses on
an equal basis, making them and their families insecure and
limiting their participation in public life and the world outside
the family unit. Also in public life, if a woman’s testimony
in court is worth only half that of a man’s, then she herself
is seen by the law as only worth half that of a man, limiting
access to justice and legal remedies. Women cannot move
freely if they need the permission of their guardian to travel
themselves or for their child to travel with her, or express
themselves if their dress is prescribed by law. Women alone
may also be subjected to punishment if they are deemed to be
a “prostitute”.
What needs to change
Equality Now continues to call for full equality in
nationality rights globally building on progress since
our advocacy reports, including The State We’re In - Ending
Sexism in Nationality Laws.29 The Global Campaign for
Equal Nationality Rights30 is also building momentum
amongst governments, UN agencies and civil society to
end sex discrimination in nationality laws.
To achieve legal equality, implement paragraphs
232(b) and (d) of the BPfA by amending or repealing any
sex discriminatory laws and providing constitutional
guarantees of non-discrimination on the basis of sex
above any other right, including to culture, tradition and
religion.
Below are examples of laws which must be amended or
repealed.