acknowledges, subject to geopolitical fluctuations. Instead of relying
on UNRWA’s existing Advisory Commission composed of 28 member
states, the review suggests transitioning to an executive board made up
of 36 member states, to seek further funding at more senior levels and
relocating the entity from Geneva to New York. 24 In practice, this scenario
preserves and deepens the same donor-driven, voluntary, and politically
contingent funding structure that has contributed to UNRWA’s ongoing
funding crisis.
Introducing an Executive Board structure, like that of United Nations
Development Programme, United Nations Population Fund and United
Nations Office for Project Services, would fundamentally change this
dynamic by shifting authority from an advisory role to a governance
model where a rotating group of states could exercise direct control over
UNRWA’s strategy, operations, and budget - as decreed by the UNGA
Resolution 48/162 of 1993 for the respective UN agencies.25
This scenario frames collapse as reform: UNRWA continues to exist, but
in a form that is compliant, donor-governed, and stripped of its political
autonomy. It institutionalizes even deeper conditionality and reinforces the
same donor-driven system that enables certain member states to dictate
the terms of support. This entrenches the voluntary funding model and
empowers states most invested in preventing the international will to
uphold the rights of Palestinian refugees and UNRWA itself. Far from
rescuing UNRWA, this pathway turns it into a humanitarian subcontractor,
a mechanism to contain and manage Palestinian displacement. Further
restructuring constitutes a retreat from the UNGA’s and CommissionerGeneral of UNRWA’s exclusive authority over a subsidiary organ,
24 Ibid., 22
25 United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA), Executive Board, accessed August 1, 2025, https://
www.unfpa.org/session-and-informals/executive-board-undp-unfpa-and-unops-annualsession-2025.
10
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents