challenges in proving their prior longterm residence in Cambodia and eligibility
for Cambodian nationality. Cambodian
officials routinely treat long-term ethnic
Vietnamese residents as ‘foreign nationals’
or ‘immigrants’, despite their strong claims
for citizenship. Often their documentation
(for some even proof of citizenship) was
lost during their displacement, confiscated
by the authorities, or viewed with
suspicion. Additionally, during Khmer
Rouge rule, civil registration records were
systematically destroyed. In 2018, in their
trial judgment in Case 002/02 before the
ECCC, judges concluded that participating
stateless Vietnamese victims had not only
experienced genocide but also suffered
‘the loss of legal status due to the loss
of documentation showing their ties to
Cambodia’.45
authorities frequently record them as
‘Vietnamese nationals’ through their
own registration processes, without
any verification procedure with the
Vietnamese government known to exist.
Today’s situation of stateless communities
of Vietnamese origin in Cambodia is
characterised by three key challenges: lack
of effective access to birth and other civil
registration; a precarious legal status due
to changing government policies and the
lack of pathways to naturalisation; and
insufficient knowledge about the scale
of the problem. Prejudices and negative
attitudes among the majority population
towards the Vietnamese minority in part
explain these challenges and further add
to group’s predicament.47
Importantly, Cambodia does not officially
recognise these non-citizen, long-term
residents of Vietnamese origin as stateless.
Responding to treaty body queries,
the state party simply noted: ‘With
regards to children born of Vietnamese
parents and living in Cambodia, they
are considered as Vietnamese. These
children are not stateless.’46 Instead, the
While
Cambodia
has
witnessed
noteworthy improvements in total birth
registration rates – reported at above 90
percent for children under the age of 548 –
there has been consistent reporting from
civil society and researchers that many
ethnic Vietnamese communities do not
have effective access to birth registration.49
In 2016, Minority Rights Organization
No effective access to birth registration:
44 Tableau, Ewa (2009) ‘Khmer Rouge Victims in Cambodia, April 1975–January 1979: A Critical
Assessment of Major Estimates’, Democratic Expert Report for the Extraordinary Chambers in the
Courts of Cambodia, D140/1/1 Public Redacted Version, 47-48.
45 ECCC Trial Chamber, ‘Case 002/02 Judgment’, E465, 16 November 2018, para. 4459. See also Sperfeldt,
Christoph (2023) ‘Nationality as Reparation? The Case 002/02 Trial Judgment at the Extraordinary
Chambers in the Courts of Cambodia’, Statelessness & Citizenship Review 5(1): 118.
46 ‘Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Situation of Human Rights in Cambodia: Comments by the
State’, UN Doc A/HRC/39/73/Add.2 (11 September 2018) 24.
47 See Frewer, Tim (2016) ‘Cambodia’s Anti-Vietnam Obsession’, The Diplomat, 6 September 2016.
<https://thediplomat.com/2016/09/cambodias-anti-vietnam-obsession/> (8 July 2024)
48 See for instance, National Institute of Statistics (2022) ‘Cambodia Socio-Economic Survey 2021’, 23.
49 Hyde, Melanie (2016), ‘Report on Access to Birth Registration for Marginalised or Vulnerable
Populations: A Case Study on Ethnic Vietnamese Minority Communities in Cambodia’, report prepared
for the Minority Rights Organization.
15