main poverty identification program.91
Although Sub-decree 291 on Identification
of Poor Households (2011) is silent on the
requirement for a legal identity document,
the questionnaires used for identifying
poor households embed a request for a
national ID card number, including the
attachment of a copy of the national ID
card.92 This implies that, in practice, a
Cambodian national ID card is required
to be recorded in IDPoor. Given the
centrality of IDPoor for the identification
of poor households (not to mention
any actual delivery of assistance), there
is a need for further inquiry into the
relationship between possession of proof
of legal identity (in particular Cambodian
nationality) and access to IDPoor by some
of the poorest and most marginalised
households.93
5.3. Land, relocations and
cross-border migration
Land ownership in Cambodia is limited
to nationals only, leaving stateless
communities and those without proof of
nationality frequently in precarious living
and housing conditions. Furthermore,
around the Tonle Sap Lake authorities
have taken measures to relocate
floating villages onto the land, citing
environmental and other regulatory
reasons.94 Many of these comprise
stateless communities of Vietnamese
origin. Kampong Chhnang province was
the first to implement relocations for more
than 10,000 people, affecting Vietnamese
and other communities alike.95 However,
the conditions of the relocation sites
differ markedly between Vietnamese and
non-Vietnamese groups. In 2019, the UN
Special Rapporteur visited some of these
sites and expressed great concern about
housing and sanitation conditions for
Vietnamese families and the general lack
of public infrastructure.96 In June 2021,
Phnom Penh authorities similarly ordered
with little notice the removal of all floating
houses on rivers surrounding the capital,
affecting some 1,300 mostly Vietnamese
households.97 Apart from disrupting
the livelihood of traditional fishing
communities, these relocations have
highlighted the precarious legal status of
91 Refer to Department of Identification of Poor Households at <https://idpoor.gov.kh/en/>
92 See IDPoor questionnaire at <https://idpoor.gov.kh/en/idpoor-questionnaire/> (17 November 2023)
93 RWI Scoping Study 2023.
94 Smith, Rhona (2021) ‘Relocating Floating Communities in Cambodia: Kampong Chhnang’, Human
Rights Quarterly 43(2): 290; and Beban, Alice et al (2024) ‘Disorientations: The Political Ecology of
“Displacing” Floating Communities from Cambodia’s Tonle Sap Lake’, Antipode: A Radical Journal of
Geography, 1-25.
95 Smith, Relocating Floating Communities in Cambodia, 295.
96 ‘Report of the Special Rapporteur on the Situation of Human Rights in Cambodia’, UN Doc A/
HRC/42/60 (27 August 2019) paras. 40-43.
97 See Nicseybon Samoeun and Danielle Keeton-Olsen (2021) ‘Floating Communities, Many Vietnamese,
Uprooted by Phnom Penh Evictions’, VOD, 11 June 2021. <https://vodenglish.news/floatingcommunities-many-vietnamese-uprooted-by-phnom-penh-evictions/> (12 July 2024)
26