2022
Statelessness & Citizenship Review
4(2)
research in favour of the Bengalis due to the risk of social and political backlash.48
There are very few exceptions to this, but one occurred in 2017, when an 18member special committee that was formed to discuss issues faced by the Bengali
community unanimously decided to ‘suggest a constitutional amendment to give
legal status to the Bengalis in Pakistan’.49 No such amendment has been suggested
or passed. Local NGOs have tried to step in to substitute for the lack of
governmental aid to Bengali Pakistani communities, providing healthcare or legal
support on a very limited basis.50
CONCLUSION
While UNHCR’s #IBelong Campaign to End Statelessness recognises and
endorses the good practices of governments ending statelessness, certain stateless
communities are in its blind spot. The Bengalis in Pakistan are one such example.
Pakistan has spent decades providing refuge to the people of Afghanistan and, for
these efforts, it deserves due praise. However, its mistreatment of Afghan
refugees, stateless Bengalis and other minorities must be addressed. The
revocation and non-issuance of CNICs by NADRA and the general consensus that
Bengalis are aliens in Pakistani society are lesser-known issues. The Bengali
stateless population deserve acceptance into Pakistani society, so they can finally
lead healthy, respectable and stable lives in their homeland.
48
49
50
Elaine Alam, ‘Closing Civic Space in Pakistan’ in South Asia State of Minorities Report 2020:
Minorities and Shrinking Civic Space (Report, The South Asia Collective, 2020) 165, 185–91.
Zia Ur Rehman, ‘Pakistan Moves towards Legalising Bengalis and Biharis, Not Rohingyas’,
Geo News (online, 18 October 2017) <www.geo.tv/latest/162968-pakistan-to-grantcitizenship-to-bengalis-and-biharis-not-rohingyas>, archived at <perma.cc/3KPG-MLKH>.
Abira Ashfaq, Understanding Urban Resilience: Migration, Displacement and Violence in
Karachi (Report, International Committee of the Red Cross, 2019) 14–15.
292