COVID-19 IMPACTS ON IMMIGRATION DETENTION: GLOBAL RESPONSES
ORGANISING FOR CHANGE: HOW WE SUPPORTED COVID-19 –
STRUCK AND HUNGER STRIKING DETAINEES IN HONG KONG
Hong Kong is a Special Administrative Region located at the edge
of Southern China, with a dense population of 7.5 million. It is home
to 530,000 ethnic minorities from the Philippines, Indonesia, India,
Nepal and other Asian countries1. Given its proximity to China, the city
experienced the first wave of COVID-19 outbreak as early as 23 January
2020, and there were over 4,800 confirmed cases by 4 September 2020.
discovery. It was mere luck that a full-blown outbreak did not follow. All
detainees were asked to conduct a COVID-19 test the next day.
People without right of abode in Hong Kong, such as overstayers, ‘illegal
workers’ and prisoners with foreign nationalities who had finished
their sentences, were detained in CIC, i.e. Castle Peak Bay Immigration
Centre. Usually around 200-400 were detained at a given time. Some
were soon released on recognizance paper and received a minimal
monthly subsidy to survive in the city. Some remained in CIC, awaiting
deportation back to their country of origin or the result of their nonrefoulement claim (a.k.a. torture claim2) applications or appeals; either
way they could be detained for prolonged periods of time, as there
was no clearly defined ‘jail term’ in CIC. The authorities justified some
unusually long detentions by the detainees’ supposed threat to public
order or high chance of abscondment3.
Since 29 June 2020, a peak of 28 male CIC detainees from India,
Pakistan, Nigeria, Zambia and Benin took part in an indefinite hunger
strike. They protested against being detained indefinitely, some for over
5 months and even up to 2 years, with no end in sight. 11 strikers entered
their 70th day of hunger strike on 7 September. 15 female detainees
reportedly conducted a brief hunger strike in solidarity in August as well.
Hunger strikes have unfortunately been common among desperate
detainees. Prolonged detention, without meaningful activity or
work and no contact with sunlight, has been physically and mentally
torturous. Many reported that ‘CIC is worse than prison’. In addition,
detainees reported appalling hygiene conditions, with frequently
blocked toilets and showers, swarms of rats and cockroaches, crowded
common areas, shared buckets of drinking water, no place to dry
clothes, and poor ventilation.
CIC concern group volunteer witnessed staff in full protective gear
coming in and out of CIC on 19 August 2020
A second COVID-19-positive case, a 22-year-old Thai male transferred
from Pik Uk Prison to CIC for detention, emerged on 5 September5. In
particular, this detainee used to work in the Prison’s Laundry Workshop
Complex that served the city’s public hospitals. The next morning, the
CIC Concern Group discovered that all visits to CIC had been suspended
until further notice.
A newly admitted detainee was tested positive for COVID-19 on
18 August 2020, another on 5 September. The cases reflected the
vulnerability of detainees in times of a pandemic. This article will detail
the threats posed by COVID-19 to detainees, and the ground-breaking
actions taken by a civil society initiative, CIC Detainees’ Right Concern
Group, as well as their impacts.
HOW COVID-19 THREATENED CIC DETAINEES
The lack of proper outbreak-prevention policies in CIC was exposed
when a confirmed case was publicised. On 16 August 2020, a Thai
overstayer, alongside 3 other new entrants, was separated from most
detainees in an ‘isolation cell’. He was identified as COVID-19 positive on
18 August and taken to the hospital4. However, detainees reported that
officers who handled his detention moved freely around CIC before the
1
2
3
4
5
24
The CIC concern group only discovered that all visits to CIC had been
suspended until further notice on 6 September 2020, outside the gates
of CIC.
There were also around 60,000 people categorised as ‘white’. Source: Census and Statistics Department of HKSAR Government. ‘Hong Kong 2016 Population
By-census – Thematic Report: Ethnic Minorities’. Retrieved from https://www.censtatd.gov.hk/hkstat/sub/sp459.jsp?productCode=B1120100 (3 Sep 2020)
Hong Kong did not sign the Convention Relating to the Status of Refugees, so recognised UN refugees can only await relocation to a third country.
See Immigration Department of HKSAR Government (2012, Dec), ‘Policy for detention pending final determination of the claimant’s torture claim’, Retrieved from
https://www.immd.gov.hk/pdf/Detention_policy_en.pdf (3 Sep 2020)
Immigration Department (2020, August 19), ‘A detainee detained at Castle Peak Bay Immigration Centre tested positive for COVID-19 19 August 2020’. Retrieved
from https://www.immd.gov.hk/eng/press/press-releases/20200819b.html (3 Sep 2020)
Immigration Department (2020, September 6), ‘A person transferred from Pik Uk Prison to Castle Peak Bay Immigration Centre for detention tests positive for
COVID-19’. Retrieved from https://www.immd.gov.hk/eng/press/press-releases/20200906.html (11 Sep 2020)
International Detention Coalition and Western Sydney University