European States’ Obligations to Repatriate the Children Detained in Camps in Northeast Syria
European States’ Obligations to
Repatriate Children Detained in
Camps in Northeast Syria
This section sets out the sources, under European and international law, of
European States’ legal obligation to proactively repatriate their child
nationals. The arguments put forward here start with three overarching
human rights considerations: the extraterritorial application of European
States’ human rights obligations in relation to their child nationals detained
in northeast Syria, the best interests of the child, and the right to be free
from discrimination. Following this, the section examines several key
substantive human rights arguments regarding: the right to nationality, the
right to access consular assistance, the right to enter one’s own country, the
right to life, the right to be free from torture and ill-treatment, the right to
liberty and security, and the right of child victims of armed conflict to
reintegration and recovery. In the context of children’s detention in the
camps in northeast Syria, the effective protection of these rights creates an
obligation to proactively repatriate the children, together with their primary
caregivers.
Proactive repatriation is not the same as simply allowing children and their
primary caregivers to enter their country of nationality if they are released or
escape from the camps and manage to return to their countries of nationality
on their own. Nor does proactive repatriation simply mean repatriating
children on a case-by-case basis, thereby prolonging their precarious
situation and discriminating against children whose caregivers or relatives
do not have the necessary resources to support legal proceedings.
Proactive repatriation means that States must arrange for the repatriation of
all of their child nationals, in accordance with the principle of “the child’s
best interests” (see Section II.B. below). In practice, this usually includes:
establishing nationality, if it is strictly necessary and with appropriate
safeguards, this can mean facilitating DNA tests to determine paternity or
maternity (see Section II.D. on the Right to Nationality); obtaining regular
assurances of their physical and psychological well-being; providing
appropriate medical care; issuing administrative documents, including
identity and travel documents, to enable children’s assisted travel to their
country of nationality; and contacting camp authorities, consular
21