126
R. Bauböck
either side of this divide are everywhere the same: young versus old, high
versus low education, urban versus rural, and – less universally so – female
versus male.1 Yet there is one further characteristic that tends to be overlooked and that is causally connected with political stances on free movement. Mobile citizens tend to vote for pro-European parties or policies and
immobile ones for anti-European ones. One of the most striking charts published by the Financial Times after the Brexit vote shows a very strong positive correlation between the percentage of local residents who did not hold
a passport in 2014 – and thus were unlikely to have travelled abroad – and
the share of the Brexit vote.2 It seems we are witnessing a political revolt of
immobile against mobile Europeans.
This may seem an odd diagnosis given that EUROSTAT data show less
than 4 per cent of EU citizens currently residing in another member state for
more than 12 months. But, as Saara Koikkalainen argues in her contribution
and as Ettore Recchi and Justyna Salamonska show in a recent survey in
seven EU countries, the numbers of mobile populations are much larger if
one counts those with some lifetime experience of intra-EU mobility and
includes transnational cognitive and network mobility. The EUCROSS
study finds 13 per cent who have lived for more than 3 months in another
European state and slightly more than 50 per cent who communicate regularly with family and friends across European borders, who have visited
another European country in the last 24 months or who watch TV in a language other than their native one or the official one of their country of residence.3 Theresa Kuhn has shown that such individual experiences of
transnationalism shape positive attitudes towards European integration but
that this effect is social stratified. Conversely, the absence of transnational
activities is likely to lead to perceptions of negative externalities of intra-EU
mobility and negative attitudes towards European integration.4
Traditional cleavages along class, religious or ethno-linguistic fault-lines
divided the political spaces of nation-states into distinct segments who lived
either in separate parts of the state territory or in separate life-worlds. These
1
2
3
4
The gender gap was especially dramatic in the recent Austrian presidential
elections: On 22 May, 60 per cent of female voters cast their ballot for the
left-liberal green candidate, while 60 per cent of males voted for the right wing
populist one.
John Burn-Murdoch in FT, 24 June 2016 (based on data from 382 voting
areas), available at https://www.ft.com/
content/1ce1a720-ce94-3c32-a689-8d2356388a1f.
Recchi, E. & J. Salámonska (2014), ‘Europe between mobility and sedentarism: Patterns of micro-transnationalism and their consequences for
European integration’. Unpublished working paper.
Kuhn, T. (2015), Experiencing European Integration: Transnational Lives and
European Identity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents