Union Citizenship for UK Citizens
Glyn Morgan
In the wake of the Brexit vote, Floris de Witte’s defence of citizenship-based
freedom of movement is as important as it is timely. In linking movement to
citizenship, as de Witte notices, those who move have a secure status in their
new country. In any member state, the new arrival is not a foreigner, not a
guest, not someone who has to apologize for being there, but a citizen whose
rights are guaranteed by the EU. No one can say: ‘you don’t belong here.’
And if they did; the response would be: ‘I have the same rights as you to live
and work anywhere in the EU.’
Now with Brexit, UK citizens will lose freedom of movement, and
Europeans resident in Britain will lose the protection afforded by Union citizenship. More worrying still, Brexit threatens to unravel the postwar
achievements of European integration. If the UK prospers in the immediate
aftermath of Brexit, other countries might follow. A Europe of nation-states
will be the outcome. The idea of a unified European polity1 powerful enough
to defend itself and project its values abroad will be lost.
The EU must act to ensure that Brexit is a failure. It can do this by crafty
deployment of a carrot and stick strategy. The stick should come in the form
of refusing the UK any privileged access to the Single Market without
accepting freedom of movement. No ‘passporting’ for the UK financial services industry—a key component of the British economy—should be
allowed. US and other foreign banks should be forced to relocate their headquarters to an EU financial centre. The EU should make crafty use of non-
trade barriers to hinder the exports of British manufacturers. If the UK wants
out of the Customs Union, then the EU should monitor in fine-grained detail,
a slow and cumbersome process, the foreign component of UK exports.
British visitors to the Continent should be required to attain expensive visas.
The carrot comes in the form of citizenship-based freedom of movement.
One step in the right direction would be for the EU to move towards a form
of Union citizenship unmediated by any prior national citizenship. At the
1
Morgan, G. (2007), The Idea of a European Superstate Public Justification and
European Integration, 2nd edition. Princeton: Princeton University Press.
© The Author(s) 2019
R. Bauböck (ed.), Debating European Citizenship, IMISCOE Research
Series, https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-319-89905-3_30
149
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents