2021
Statelessness & Citizenship Review
3(1)
‘an authentic reflection of what it means to be stateless in today’s world in order
to create a realistic understanding of what is needed to improve stateless people’s
situations’. 5
In his thought-provoking piece in this issue, Haqqi Bahram’s ‘Towards a
Stateless Standpoint Epistemology’ seeks to ‘introduce and propose the concept
of stateless standpoint epistemology as an approach in statelessness research for
realigning knowledge with stateless persons’ experiences’. 6 This, he explains,
‘[b]asically … means starting knowledge about statelessness from the standpoints
of stateless persons’. 7 This contribution pushes us as statelessness scholars to
‘address the existing gap of methodological discussions about how and what
knowledge of statelessness is produced, something that is much needed but is often
marginally stated or left out from the body of research’. 8
The Critique and Commentary part of this volume offers a set of timely, diverse
and insightful perspectives on COVID-19 and statelessness that are strongly
grounded in the experiences of the stateless, undocumented and those at risk of
statelessness. This section is now in the very capable hands of Associate Professor
Jamie Liew, taking over from Dr Kristy Belton who did a truly outstanding job in
shaping this section of the Review, introducing dedicated thematic foci such as the
‘Reflection on Statelessness Studies’ (Volume 1(1)), and the symposium on
‘Statelessness and Slavery’ (Volume 2(1)). As Jamie explains, in bringing together
this volume’s COVID-19 focused pieces, it is important to recognise that ‘[e]ach
writer is either from that community, or has work and/or research embedded in the
community they are writing about’. 9 As she further notes, in taking this approach,
these commentaries expose ‘how the lack of status is not only the fundamental
reason why stateless and undocumented persons face abuse, exploitation, poverty
and other challenges but how their status is politically constructed’, and also that
‘each piece also provides some hope that the pandemic offers a moment of
change’. 10
Other new approaches and critiques are evident in some of the other excellent
contributions to this bumper issue of the Statelessness & Citizenship Review,
which, in addition to articles, case notes and book reviews on a diverse range of
issues, and the thematic focus on COVID-19 and statelessness, also features a
forthcoming symposium on ‘Citizenship and Statelessness in India’, edited by
guest editor Dr Adil Hasan Khan.
Malak Benslama-Dabdoub’s article, ‘Colonial Legacies in Syrian Nationality
Law and the Risk of Statelessness’ is a highly original and ground-breaking tour
de force of the long and complex history of Syria as a nation-state, tracing the
colonial roots of Syrian legislation governing nationality from the fall of the
Ottoman Empire, through to colonial mandates, and post-independence
developments. Her aim is to offer a ‘critical legal and historical analysis’ to reveal
‘the hidden colonial legacies of Syrian citizenship, by highlighting the
responsibility of European colonial powers in introducing gender-based
5
6
7
8
9
10
ibid.
Haqqi Bahram, ‘Towards a Stateless Standpoint Epistemology’ (2021) 3(1) Statelessness &
Citizenship Review 113, 114 (emphasis added).
ibid.
ibid.
Jamie Liew, ‘Statelessness and COVID-19: An Introduction’, 2021) 3(1) Statelessness &
Citizenship Review 120.
ibid 121.
2