Some refugees described the violence they experienced
while in Myanmar and their fears about going back;
as earlier research (Xchange, 2018: 37) found, ‘most
people’s fears can be seen to be derived from their
previously lived or witnessed traumatic experiences,
including rape, torture, and the murder of adults
and children, among other incidents’. One man we
interviewed, in his late fifties, said that he did not
want to go back to Myanmar currently ‘because the
military killed a lot of Rohingya people and this
fear is still carrying in our mind and we are thinking
that if we will go back to Myanmar either today or
tomorrow the military will attack us again and we
don’t want to face that another time’. A widow we
spoke to with five children shared similar concerns:
she described her husband and small children being
killed and said there was nothing for her in Myanmar
– no matter what, she did not want to return.
3.3.2 Options if they do not return
We also asked refugees where they would want to live
if they were not able to return to Myanmar in the next
5–10 years. Of those who took part in the quantitative
survey, 79% wanted to stay in their current camp with
their family and those they currently lived with. The
qualitative research confirmed these results.
Figure 2: Where Rohingya refugees would
want to live if they were not able to return to
Myanmar in the next 5–10 years
Stay in the camps
Live in the host community in and around Cox’s Bazar
Somewhere else in Bangladesh with yoru family
Resettled in another country with your family
Other
2%
3%
7%
9%
79%
When asked why they wanted to stay in the camps,
refugees said they felt settled where they were, close
to relatives and people they knew, and did not want
the disruption of moving again. Some explained they
had never travelled from the area around their home
since coming to Bangladesh – during a focus group
in Shamlapur, one woman said ‘Since we have come
here from Myanmar 15 years ago I have never seen
anything outside Shamlapur. Before we didn’t know
anything about other areas, that’s why we have never
gone outside Shamlapur, and we didn’t have enough
transport fare which is why we couldn’t go outside.
Now there are checkpoints and the military wouldn’t
allow us to pass. The furthest any of us have gone
is Shamlapur market and nearby there’. Refugees
also cited mutually understood language, cultural
familiarity and established relationships with those
in the local community as being reasons to stay: one
man said ‘here in the camp the locals are cooperative
to us so that’s why I want to live here’; another said
‘If we will move from here anywhere in Bangladesh
we will not be able to adjust because the local
language here is similar. Their language is similar so
we are adjusted here and we can easily understand
what the locals want. We are familiar to the locals
and the locals are familiar to us’.
Few refugees said that they wanted to stay where they
were because they felt their living conditions would
improve. Rather, the status quo was preferred to the
uncertainty and risks of change. One woman at a
focus group in Shamlapur said she was worried that if
she was registered as a refugee she would be sent back
to Myanmar, and she did not want to go. One elderly
woman said that she had heard that refugees could
be relocated to an island (Bhashan Char), but did not
want to go. Refugees have so far been highly reluctant
to move there: as Antara (2019) writes, ‘The assurance
of a relatively-comfortable life on the remote island,
made by the Bangladeshi Government, is not enough
to convince them. Most Rohingya refugees are
unwilling to relocate there as they fear death by
starvation, floods, and a lack of humanitarian aid’. As
it stands, the possibility of being sent to an isolated
island like Bhashan Char exemplifies the very real
concerns Rohingya refugees have about moving from
where they are currently.
For the few who wanted to live elsewhere in
Bangladesh, this was mostly to escape overcrowding
or their destitute situation in the camps, because they
had family living elsewhere or because they could
envision a better future elsewhere. One 35-year-old
woman in Unchiprang said ‘I would like to stay in
Cox’s Bazar. In town. It is a bit congested here. The
Humanitarian Policy Group
15