Example from Belgium—The right to
express and be heard
The Belgian Constitution art. 22bis provides
that “Each child has the right to express his
or her views in all matters affecting him or
her, the views of the child being given due
weight in accordance with his or her age
and maturity.” In addition, in relation to civil
matters, the judicial code provides that any
child over 12 years of age has not only the
right to be heard, but also to refuse to be
heard, in the procedures relating to parental
authority. In other words, there is a requirement to summon the child, but the child
does not have to appear nor to express himself or herself. If the child is under 12 years
of age, the judge may hear the child upon his
or her request, or that of his or her parents,
the public prosecutor’s office or on his or
her own initiative. The judge may refuse, by
a reasoned decision, to grant that request,
unless it comes from the child him or herself or from the public prosecutor’s office.
1.3 Child Rights–based Approach to States’
Security Concerns
75.
In implementing a human and child rights–
based approach, the four principles summarized
above under the Convention on the Rights of the
Child and other international instruments provide
the key framework. In addition, the following considerations should guide the treatment of children affected by the foreign fighter phenomenon,
including in situations in which such children are
considered security risks.
1.3.1. Treatment of Children Primarily as
Victims
76.
International law requires that States
adopt a human and child rights–based
approach that views those children first and
foremost as victims, while considering security
concerns. In fact, protecting and fulfilling the
rights of children as victims is also critical for
States’ security interests because it prevents
exploitation of any resentment and grievances
towards the State by designated terrorist
groups.137
77.
Children affected by the foreign fighter
phenomenon are often victims at multiple levels.
They may be victims of a hostile environment in
which their rights are denied, including the right
to development and education. Children may
have been victims of recruitment and use by
designated terrorist groups. Children may be
victims of arbitrary detention, mistreatment
and abuse for alleged association with groups
designated as terrorist groups or the alleged
association of family members. Children may
suffer from stigma and discrimination in the long
term, including from their own communities, in
ways that manifest differently for boys and girls.
78.
Children who have participated in the
activities of terrorist groups should be viewed
primarily as victims, while taking into account
the individual circumstances and issues related
to the case, though investigation and prosecution in line with international juvenile standards
of a child above the minimum age of criminal
responsibility are not precluded. In this regard,
the Security Council has expressed grave con-
137 Plan of Action to Prevent Violent Extremism (2015), para.
27; see also the Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989),
arts. 38, 39 and 40 on protecting children who are victims of
armed conflict.
35.