The right to own movable and immovable property is difficult for the stateless as it usually
falls under the laws governing ownership of real estate by foreigners. In some laws (like
Kuwait) the restrictions on foreign ownership is greater, as only nationals of Arab states can
own property. Stateless are hence left without such right. In Lebanon, decree No. 11614
relating to real estate ownership by foreigners, stipulates in article 1 that persons of a non
recognized state cannot own property. This article, intended to disallow Palestinians from
owning property as a decision not to accept their permanent settlement, also indirectly affects
the remaining stateless groups in Lebanon.
Civil status laws of the six countries were drafted primarily with citizens in mind. Stateless
persons, particularly those without any identification documents, are therefore not benefiting
from adequate civil status registration. The main problem that arises here is the inability to
register births, marriages, deaths, divorces, and hence, the stateless are left without clarity of
their status and may easily fall into illegality or illegitimacy.
The laws of the six countries are different in regard to the right to work and benefit from
social security. In principle, it is difficult for stateless persons to access jobs whether in the
private or the public sector. In Lebanon for example, a ministerial decision has restricted 73
job positions in the private sector to Lebanese only, and the laws governing various
professions, especially syndicated professions, require the principle of reciprocity in hiring
non-Lebanese; stateless persons of course are not nationals of a state that can provide such
reciprocity.
The situation is similar in terms of access to social security, as the laws of the six countries
usually stipulate for reciprocity when relating to benefiting foreigners. Hence, stateless
persons, despite being exempted from reciprocity obligations by international conventions,
find themselves not enjoying any social security benefits even if they do work in their
country of residence.
In GCC countries, foreigners may work in public authorities if there are no nationals to fill
the openings. Bidoon, however, are not allowed access to such positions since they are not
considered foreigners, but neither are they citizens, so they fall in the in-between category of
illegal or undocumented residents. This wasn't always the case In Kuwait since Bidoon had
indeed worked for public entities and served in the police and armed forces in the 1980’s.
After the Iraqi invasion, however, they were expelled from those jobs due to the perception
that they had collaborated with the Iraqi occupiers.
Free public education is usually restricted to citizens as per the provisions of constitutions,
although several countries do allow for refugees to benefit from primary education, for
example. Laws and/or ministerial decisions in the six countries clearly guarantee free
education citizens. Stateless persons have to use public education facilities, paying high
tuition fees if they can afford them.
As to Intellectual Property rights, in principle the copyright belongs to the author regardless
of registration as per Berne Convention. However, even this convention refers to the citizen
of member countries, and hence, its applicability to stateless persons is questionable.
34