4.2.1 Dutch aliens law in respect of stateless persons:
the “no-fault residence permit”
103. As stated before there is no specific procedure to establish statelessness. The basic
premise of Dutch aliens’ policy is that all aliens who do not have the right to stay in
the Netherlands can and should in principle return to their country of origin.146 The
government has frequently stated that it has no knowledge of countries not complying
with their obligation under international law to take back their own nationals.147
104. However, confronted with unreturnable aliens, the so-called “no-fault” procedure for
obtaining a residence permit was introduced: an alien whose asylum application has
been rejected, but also irregular, undocumented or unreturnable persons, can be
granted a residence permit for a limited time (een verblijfsvergunning regulier voor
bepaalde tijd) under Article 3.4(1)w in conjunction with Article 3.6(1a) of the Aliens
Decree (Vreemdelingenbesluit) if the alien is unable to leave the Netherlands through
no fault of his or her own. The residence permit is a so-called no-fault residence permit
(buitenschuldvergunning),148 which is granted on condition that the alien leaves the
Netherlands if this becomes possible at a later stage.149 After three years the holder of
the no-fault residence permit becomes eligible for another residence permit for limited
time, the so-called residence permit for limited time under the limitation “prolonged
residence” (verblijfsvergunning regulier onder de beperking “voortgezet verblijf”, see
Article 3.4(1)u of the Aliens Decree). The latter permit differs from the no-fault residence
permit in that an employment permit150 is no longer required, thus making access to the
labour market easier.
105. Under the current no-fault procedure151 the burden of proof lies exclusively with the
applicant. The Aliens Act Implementation Guidelines explain that this approach is
allowed under the 1954 Convention, because it contains no procedural provisions. The
assessment of the evidence is not the exclusive privilege of a specifically designated
judicial or administrative authority, but pertains to the normal tasks of the IND.152
106. As reception facilities are not provided during the no-fault procedure, most stateless
foreigners who arrive in the Netherlands in an irregular manner try the asylum procedure
first as this procedure provides reception facilities. Many such people are therefore
pushed into starting an asylum procedure, even if they have no interest in doing so.
44
146
H.W. Groeneweg and J.H. van der Winden, eds., Commentaar Vreemdelingenwet 2000. Editie
2004-2005 (Den Haag: Sdu uitgevers, 2004), 300.
147
Tweede Kamer, 2009-2010, 19 637, nr. 1336, p. 3. See also J. Kleijne, Artikelsgewijs commentaar
op de Vreemdelingenwet 2000 en het Vreemdelingenbesluit 2000 (Deventer: Kluwer, 2001), 250.
148
luchtelingenWerk Nederland, “Geen Pardon, geen Terugkeer. De stand van zaken rond de
V
uitvoering van het Project Terugkeer”, (2006), 29-33.
149
luchtelingenWerk Nederland, “Geen Pardon, geen Terugkeer. De stand van zaken rond de
V
uitvoering van het Project Terugkeer”, (2006), 29-33.
150
An employment permit (tewerkstellingsvergunning) is compulsory for employers wishing to employ
someone from outside the European Economic Area, which includes the EU, Norway, Iceland and
Liechtenstein.
151
This procedure is laid down in paragraph B14/3 of the Aliens Act Implementation Guidelines.
152
See B11/17.2 of the Aliens Act Implementation Guidelines.
Mapping statelessness