from citizenship to stateless citizenship179
men and women, enabling them to control and monopolize epistemological
production, whereas the marginalized Other such as Palestinians and
Mizrahi Jews tend to be relegated to an inferior position with much less
access to power and resources, negatively affecting their production of
knowledge and human capital development (Abdo 2011, 8–9).
Perhaps most important for our purposes here is that Abdo focuses her
examination of the processes of exclusion, racialization and exploitation
that simultaneously disenfranchise women in Israel through a critical feminist reading of citizenship. The relations of exclusion that produce and
reproduce the inferior status and development of women in Israel, mainly
Palestinian and Mizrahi Jewish, but to some extent also Ashkenazi Jewish
women, are made possible and reinforced by the structure of Israeli citizenship. As such, an examination of the gendered and racialized boundaries of
citizenship in Israel is, for Abdo, part and parcel of any genuine challenge to
Israel’s state system and its policies and practices of exclusion.
Stateless Citizenship
Of course, we have not exhaustively examined all of the kinds of social
science research on the Palestinians in Israel, nor have we covered all of
the formulations of Palestinian citizenship put forward by scholars and
theorists. Yet, from the above small sampling of the scholarship on Arab
citizens, and specifically on the dynamics of their citizenship, we already
have a range of impressive analytical and conceptual paradigms at hand
that seek to outline the practical and theoretical effects of the Zionist fusing of ‘Jewish’ and ‘Israeli’ identity on Arab citizenship.
As shown above, the academic literature has largely focused on the question of what Palestinian citizenship entails: What are the levels and sublevels of citizenship in Israel? What kinds of rights and privileges are
provided to Arabs by virtue of their citizenship? What is the relationship
between Arab citizenship and the project of Judaization? Between Israeli
citizenship and Jewish ethno-nationalism? Between a systematically stratified citizenship and Arab political, cultural, economic and social (under)
development? By and large, the academic literature has tried to make analytical sense of what has led – through a multifaceted range of exclusionary
legal, social and political developments since Israel’s founding – to a deepening internal and disparate disconnect between de jure and de facto citizenship for the Arabs in Israel. In doing so, it has described the Israeli
citizenship of its Palestinian population as a one-way citizenship, hegemonic citizenship, illusory citizenship, shrinking citizenship, ghettoized
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents