CHAPTER SIX
THE ANATOMY OF STATELESS CITIZENSHIP
To recap, the project of stateless citizenship is not to examine the Israeli
citizenship of Palestinians through an account of what is lacking, absent,
missing or deficient, in terms of rights, benefits, identity and representation. That much follows under the rubric of the what of Arab citizenship
which has, as mentioned, been extensively documented and addressed
by critical Palestinian and Israeli social science research. Instead, the
intention here is to analyze the how; namely the conceptual and political
dynamics of Israeli citizenship itself, as both a theoretical and practical
notion. And when we begin our analysis from the condition of Arabs with
Israeli citizenship, we realize that the problem extends from the racialized
structures of Zionism to the ways in which the existing relations of exclusion in classical liberal citizenship are employed, reversed and enhanced
by the Israeli incorporation regime. Thus, central to my account of the
purpose, dynamic and structure of Israeli citizenship will be a focus on the
embedded relations of exclusion in the concept of citizenship itself.
Evident from the small sampling of the existing scholarship in the
previous chapter is that the deficiencies and contradictions of the citizenship offered to Israel’s non-Jewish population have been extensively
documented. That the Palestinian citizens of Israel are not placed on an
equal conceptual, ideological, political or even legal footing with their
Jewish counterparts1 is no longer uncharted academic or political territory. Indeed, at a very rooted level, and despite their citizenship status, the
Palestinian citizens of Israel remain stateless in the Jewish state. Thus far,
my examination has shown that the mechanisms of control and exclusion
developing out of the Zionist incorporation regime shape both the changing settler-colonial boundaries of the Israeli polity and, by extension, its
hierarchical citizenship framework. The design of Israel’s incorporation
regime demarcates Palestinian-Arab access to citizenship rights and
1 The use of the term compatriots would be misleading here because, as explained, the
State of Israel is, by its self-definition, not theirs (it does not belong to the Arabs). Arabs and
Jews in Israel do not exist as equal countrymen and countrywomen; they are not ‘with’ the
‘homeland’ and they are excluded from (or do not share in) the existential, ideological,
political and legal makeup of the state. As such, it is more apt to say that, in the Zionist
framework, Jewish citizens are the counterparts of the Palestinian-Arab citizenry.
Select target paragraph3
Connect to a paragraph
Connect to an entity
Disable highlights
Add to table of contents